Marilyn R. Pukkila, a Tolkien scholar and Research Librarian Emerita, joins the discussion on the Valaquenta, unveiling the divine complexities of Tolkien's pantheon. They delve into the Valar and Maiar, exploring their relationships and moral dilemmas. Fascinatingly, Pukkila highlights Nienna's evolution from grief to compassion, reflecting Tolkien's own hardships. The conversation weaves through themes of storytelling and human connection, revealing how grief and creation shape the understanding of good and evil in Tolkien’s mythology.

Join John and guest Marilyn R. Pukkila, a Tolkien scholar and librarian, as they deep dive into the tragic tale of Maeglin from The Silmarillion. They examine the dark legacy of Eöl, the family tensions in Gondolin, and the shadowy themes of love and betrayal. Marilyn highlights how patriarchal influences shape character dynamics, while also addressing sensitive topics like consent and trauma. Their engaging discussion spans the moral complexities of Elven relationships and even touches on the enchanting lore of hidden elven realms.

Marilyn R. Pukkila, a Tolkien expert and Research Librarian Emerita, joins the conversation to explore the rich depths of The Silmarillion. They dive into the Silmarils' origins, discussing how Fëanor’s ambition reflects a cautionary tale about creation. The chat also unpacks the Noldor’s family tensions and their fallout. Marilyn dissects Melkor's manipulation and the emergence of Ungoliant, examining the dark themes of power and betrayal. Listeners are invited to consider the interplay between light and dark in Tolkien’s mythos.

Marilyn R. Pukkila, Research & Instruction Librarian Emerita at Colby College and an expert on Tolkien, joins the discussion focusing on the aftermath of the two trees' destruction and the significance of grief in healing. They delve into the weakening of Morgoth and explore complex themes like free will and divine compassion through the actions of the Valar. The conversation also touches on the duality of good and evil, with reflections on characters such as Fëanor, and the podcast engages listeners with themes of creativity and the challenges of responsibility.

Join Marilyn R. Pukkila, a Tolkien scholar and librarian emerita, as she delves into the awakening of men in The Silmarillion. The discussion unveils the acceleration of time and the perceived inaction of the Valar. Topics include the complex dynamics between men and elves, and the implications of mortality and free will. Marilyn also tackles Tolkien's colonial influences, portraying his empathy for oppressed peoples amid epic conflicts. This insightful conversation reveals the intertwined fates of Middle-earth's races and the broader themes of love, legacy, and choice.