The Lorehounds Silmarillion Stories - E13 - Men
Apr 21, 2024
Join Marilyn R. Pukkila, a Tolkien scholar and librarian emerita, as she delves into the awakening of men in The Silmarillion. The discussion unveils the acceleration of time and the perceived inaction of the Valar. Topics include the complex dynamics between men and elves, and the implications of mortality and free will. Marilyn also tackles Tolkien's colonial influences, portraying his empathy for oppressed peoples amid epic conflicts. This insightful conversation reveals the intertwined fates of Middle-earth's races and the broader themes of love, legacy, and choice.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Men in Middle-earth
- Tolkien uses "men" as an inclusive term for all humans in Middle-earth, reflecting literary traditions.
- This choice might relate to the male-dominated narratives in sources like sagas and epics.
Valar Inaction
- The Valar's inaction in Middle-earth seems like negligence.
- However, they have reasons, including past experiences and the fear of causing destruction.
Valar's Prolonged Inaction
- The Valar's caution is understandable, but their prolonged inaction is questionable.
- They waited until the situation worsened before intervening, raising questions about their leadership.