Silmarillion Stories - E12 - The Sun and Moon and the Hiding of Valinor
Jan 7, 2024
auto_awesome
Marilyn R. Pukkila, Research & Instruction Librarian Emerita at Colby College and an expert on Tolkien, joins the discussion focusing on the aftermath of the two trees' destruction and the significance of grief in healing. They delve into the weakening of Morgoth and explore complex themes like free will and divine compassion through the actions of the Valar. The conversation also touches on the duality of good and evil, with reflections on characters such as Fëanor, and the podcast engages listeners with themes of creativity and the challenges of responsibility.
The aftermath of the destruction of the two trees signifies a pivotal transformation, highlighting themes of hope and renewal in Tolkien's mythology.
Exploration of Feanor’s character reveals the tension between ambition and consequence, affecting the destinies of those around him in Middle-earth.
Morgoth's diminishing power amidst ongoing conflict embodies the cyclical nature of good and evil, illustrating the depth of Tolkien's storytelling.
Deep dives
Enhanced Boost Membership Benefits
The new Boost membership at Bakers now includes additional streaming options such as Disney Plus with ads, Hulu with ads, or ESPN Plus. Members can enjoy unlimited free delivery, double fuel points, and exclusive offers, making grocery shopping easier and more rewarding. These enhancements aim to provide convenience and value, allowing members to save while enjoying a variety of entertainment options. Sign-up for the Boost membership continues to be promoted as a way to experience these savings and services.
Exploration of The Silmarillion
The discussion highlights the significance of 'Of the Sun and Moon and The Hiding of Valinor,' emphasizing the lore surrounding the sun, moon, and the Valar's increasing defenses. The hosts dissect the intricate world-building found within the chapter, noting how Tolkien's poetic language elevates the narrative. They express appreciation for revisiting such chapters, which may not be as well-known yet contain vital lore and compelling storytelling. The hosts encourage engagement from listeners, inviting them to share their feedback and thoughts on these themes.
Character Depth and Analysis
The episode delves into character exploration, particularly focusing on Feanor and his impact on Middle-earth's narrative. The Valar's reactions and emotions regarding Feanor's fall from grace are examined, capturing the depth of his character and the broader implications for the elvenkind. The dialogue emphasizes grief and potential, and how choices define the characters’ destinies within Tolkien’s world. The interaction showcases the tension between ambition and consequence, urging listeners to consider the depth of these characters as representatives of broader themes in Tolkien’s work.
Tensions Between Good and Evil
The series of conflicts that unfold, particularly Morgoth's attack on the moon, starkly highlight the ongoing struggle between good and evil. As Morgoth becomes increasingly bound to the world, his spread of malice is seen as a diminishing force, reflecting the idea that evil contains the seeds of its own destruction. The commentary reveals the cyclical nature of conflict in Tolkien's lore, where actions have lasting consequences, and the line between good and evil often blurs. This complexity adds richness to the storytelling, engaging listeners to reflect on similar themes in their own narratives.
The Arrival of the Sun and Moon
The creation of the sun and moon emerges as a pivotal moment in Tolkien's mythology, symbolizing hope and renewal after despair. The cooperative efforts of the Valar to bring life back after tragedy illustrates themes of healing and growth, particularly through Nienna's weeping and its transformative power. The chapter also explores the transition from starlight to sunlight, fundamentally changing the world and affecting the elves' relationship with their environment. This moment is framed as a culmination of character dynamics, thematic depth, and Tolkien's intricate world-building.
David and John are joined by Marilyn R. Pukkila to discuss Of the Sun and Moon and the Hiding of Valinor, the twelfth story in The Silmarillion. They discuss the aftermath of the destruction of the two trees, the importance of grief in healing, and the weakening of Morgoth.
Find us on Twitter @thelorehounds, on Twitch at twitch.tv/thelorehounds, or join us for further discussion of all things Tolkien over on our Discord Server.
Silmarillion Stories Reading Schedule 2024
January 2024 - Of the Sun and Moon and the Hiding of Valinor
February 2024 - Of Men
March 2024 - Of the Return of the Noldor
April 2024 - Of Beleriand and its Realms
May 2024 - Of the Noldor in Beleriand
June 2024 - Of Maeglin
July 2024 - Of the Coming of Men into the West
August 2024 - Of the Ruin of Beleriand and the Fall of Fingolfin
September 2024 - Of Beren and Luthien (Part 1)
October 2024 - Of Beren and Luthien (Part 2)
November 2024 - Of the Fifth Battle - Nirnaeth Arnoediad
December 2024 - Of Turin Turambar
Any opinions stated are ours personally and do not reflect the opinion of or belong to any employers or other entities.