
David Edmonds
Author and journalist who wrote the book Death in a Shallow Pond about Peter Singer's drowning-child thought experiment; featured guest discussing the origins, implications, and criticisms of the thought experiment.
Top 10 podcasts with David Edmonds
Ranked by the Snipd community

60 snips
Oct 5, 2025 • 19min
David Edmonds on Peter Singer's Shallow Pond Thought Experiment
 David Edmonds, an author and journalist known for his book 'Death in a Shallow Pond', dives into Peter Singer's thought experiment about a drowning child. He explores the moral implications of choosing between saving a child or prioritizing personal belongings. Topics include applying this scenario to global poverty, the challenges of impartial ethics, and the demanding nature of Singer's views. Edmonds also discusses Effective Altruism and the importance of impact in charity, tackling criticisms and misconceptions surrounding the movement. 

20 snips
Feb 19, 2024 • 21min
James Klagge on Wittgenstein
 James Klagge, an expert on Wittgenstein, discusses his affluent upbringing, transition to philosophy, and influences like Russell in the Tractatus. They delve into how Wittgenstein's war experiences shaped his philosophical themes and contrast with the Vienna Circle's views on ethics and religion. 

13 snips
Apr 10, 2024 • 21min
David Edmonds on the Life and Philosophy of Derek Parfit
 David Edmonds discusses the life and philosophy of Derek Parfit, focusing on his views on personal identity, selflessness, the pressures behind 'Reasons and Persons', and the intersection of Parfit's photography and philosophy. 

10 snips
Sep 29, 2025 • 42min
Steven Pinker on common knowledge
 Join Steven Pinker, a cognitive psychologist and bestselling author, as he unravels the complexities of common knowledge and its role in human behavior. He explores how social media shapes beliefs and community norms. Aleks Krotoski dives into the ambitions of Silicon Valley's 'immortalists' and their radical life-extension pursuits, revealing the extremes some will go to defy mortality. David Edmonds discusses Peter Singer's moral theories around our obligations to help others, challenging listeners to rethink proximity in altruism. Prepare for a thought-provoking conversation! 

9 snips
Aug 4, 2024 • 15min
Elizabeth Harman on Moral Heroes
 Elizabeth Harman, a philosopher known for her work on moral reasoning, discusses the concept of moral heroes, those who surpass obligatory actions. She explores the complexities of heroism versus moral obligations and the challenges of personal sacrifice. David Edmonds joins the conversation to navigate the ethics of charitable acts and the moral responsibilities we hold, particularly regarding global needs. They also touch on controversial topics like moral vegetarianism, emphasizing the importance of understanding diverse moral perspectives. 

Sep 6, 2023 • 55min
The Philosophy of Derek Parfit with David Edmonds
 David Edmonds, British philosopher and radio feature maker at the BBC World Service, discusses the controversial legacy of philosopher Derek Parfit. Topics include Parfit's influence on obligations to future people, his unusual relationship with his body, the consequences of taking action on climate change, the Non-identity Problem and moral dilemmas, introduction to Parfit's work, and a famous thought experiment in moral philosophy. 

Oct 22, 2025 • 49min
David Edmonds on Death in a Shallow Pond
 In this engaging discussion, journalist David Edmonds delves into Peter Singer's shallow pond thought experiment, which challenges our moral obligations toward distant strangers. He explains how this concept paved the way for the Effective Altruism movement, designed to maximize charitable impact. Edmonds also addresses critiques of the movement, including its demandingness and the shift towards longtermism, stressing the importance of balancing individual aid with systemic change. Thought experiments, he argues, can significantly shape real-world ethics and actions. 

Sep 1, 2025 • 56min
David Edmonds, "Death in a Shallow Pond: A Philosopher, a Drowning Child, and Strangers in Need" (Princeton UP, 2025)
 David Edmonds, a distinguished philosopher and author at Oxford's Uehiro Institute, delves into Peter Singer's provocative shallow pond thought experiment. He explores the moral implications of saving a drowning child versus the costs of inaction—like losing expensive shoes. The conversation challenges the concept of Effective Altruism, examining criticisms that it perpetuates poverty and ignores systemic issues. Edmonds also discusses the psychological impact of charity messaging and the ethical dilemmas posed by billionaire philanthropy and inequality. 

Aug 7, 2023 • 1h 15min
#250 - Parfit: A Dialogue with David Edmonds
 David Edmonds, a distinguished philosopher and author, delves into the life and thoughts of Derek Parfit, a pivotal figure in moral philosophy. They explore Parfit's unique upbringing in a religious family and how it fueled his quest for secular morality. The discussion covers his impactful works, including 'Reasons and Persons', and delves into his ideas on personal identity, utilitarianism, and the non-identity problem. Edmonds also reflects on Parfit's poetic talents and photographic passions, illustrating the complexity of his character and legacy. 

Nov 9, 2021 • 1h 2min
#71: David Edmonds on Turning Philosophy into a Career
 David Edmonds, a philosopher and former BBC World Service broadcaster, discusses his unique journey in merging philosophy with a successful career. He shares insights on how A.J. Ayer's work ignited his passion for philosophy and reflects on ethical dilemmas in meta-ethics. Edmonds explains the evolution of his engaging podcast, Philosophy Bites, emphasizing the art of interviewing with techniques like active listening and concise editing. He also contemplates the balance between breadth and specialization in journalism, revealing how storytelling enhances public philosophy. 


