Experience and craftsmanship set boxers of the past apart from modern fighters.
The decline of boxing as an art form is attributed to the erosion of technique, craftsmanship, and defensive skills.
Timing and frequency of fights play a crucial role in a fighter's success, with regular fights at shorter intervals helping fighters hone their timing and judgment.
Deep dives
Boxing: The Sport Where the Past Outshines the Present
Boxing is a unique sport where the athletes of the past are considered superior to the athletes of today. While most sports see improvements in athleticism and performance over time, boxing seems to defy this trend. Mike Silver, a renowned boxing expert and author of 'The Arc of Boxing: The Rise and Decline of the Sweet Science', argues that boxers from the past had an edge over modern boxers due to factors like experience, craftsmanship, and technique. The abundance of weight classes in boxing provides a better comparison of performance across eras, as fighters of the same weight can be compared. Even in the heavyweight division, where size differences exist, the past fighters have proven their ability to defeat larger opponents. Silver also highlights how the sport has evolved, with modern boxing becoming more brutal and lacking the artistry and skill of the past. The emphasis on knockouts and power has diminished the beauty and technique that once characterized the sport. Experts and former fighters also point out the importance of experience and intangible qualities like mental toughness and craftsmanship that were more prevalent in the past. Overall, boxing stands out as the sport where the athletes of the past shine brighter than those of the present.
The Role of Experience and Intangibles
Experience is a crucial factor that sets boxers of the past apart from modern fighters. Boxers in earlier eras fought more frequently and had significantly more matches under their belts, allowing them to develop their skills and knowledge of the sport. This deep reservoir of experience provided them with the tools to offset any physical advantages possessed by their opponents. Additionally, the quality of competition played a crucial role in developing the craftiness, technique, and defensive skills of past boxers. The lack of such competitive opportunities in the modern era, along with dilution of talent due to the proliferation of weight classes and sanctioning bodies, has impacted the skill level of contemporary fighters. The intangibles, such as toughness and mental fortitude, were also more prevalent in the boxers of the past. These intangible qualities, combined with technical prowess, created a unique blend of artistry and brutality that is often missing in modern boxing.
The Lost Art and Language of Boxing
The decline of boxing as an art form is attributed to the erosion of technique, craftsmanship, and defensive skills. Modern fighters are noted for their lack of certain classic moves, such as bending and weaving, sliding in, using feints, and utilizing the many subtleties of the sport. The absence of proper teaching and transmission of these skills has contributed to the loss of ring craftiness and subtlety in boxing. The decline in the appreciation of defensive skills and the preference for exciting brawls have shaped the modern boxing landscape. The focus on knockouts and power has shifted the attention away from the elegant and nuanced strategies that were once admired. As a result, the sport has become more brutal, emphasizing raw violence over the art of boxing. Experts and fans have expressed concerns about the lack of beauty and skill in modern boxing bouts, calling for a return to the technical and strategic elements that made boxing a captivating and sophisticated sport.
The importance of timing and frequency of fights
In boxing, timing and frequency of fights play a crucial role in a fighter's success. The ability to time punches and judge distance is essential, and fighters who compete more often have a distinct advantage in developing these skills. Ring rust can affect a boxer's performance after a long layoff, as seen with Muhammad Ali. Regular and repetitive fights at shorter intervals help fighters hone their timing and judgment. The experience gained from fighting a variety of styles strengthens their overall abilities.
The lost knowledge and skills of boxing's past
Boxing has lost the knowledge and skills of trainers and fighters from the past. The conditioning, technique, and finer points of the craft have vanished, making it impossible to recreate fighters from previous eras. Modern technology advancements, such as weight training and steroids, have changed the physicality of boxers, but these methods do not necessarily correlate with increased power or success in boxing. The mental toughness, experience, and unique skills possessed by past fighters cannot be easily replicated, making it difficult to judge their greatness compared to modern fighters.
Ready for an argument? Like Dan's quote voice? Waiting to hear Dan discuss boxing? Then you've hit the trifecta. Boxing expert Mike Silver and Dan discuss whether today's modern fighters could compete with those of yesteryear. 1. The Arc of Boxing: The Rise and Decline of the Sweet Science by Mike Silver 2. The Night the Referee Hit Back: Memorable Moments from the World of Boxing by Mike Silver 3. Stars in the Ring: Jewish Champions in the Golden Age of Boxing: A Photographic History by Mike Silver
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode