Bernarr Macfadden laid the foundation for modern health and fitness media, with his passion for physical fitness and the creation of the highly successful magazine Physical Culture.
Macfadden's magazines promoted plant-based diets, portion control, and physical exercise as solutions to health issues, shaping the genre of confessional and personal narrative publications.
Macfadden's publishing empire extended beyond health and fitness magazines, with the creation of True Story and the employment of influential media personalities, laying the foundation for modern reality television and personal branding.
Deep dives
Bernard McFadden: The Eccentric Pioneer of Physical Culture
Bernard McFadden, an ambitious eccentric, laid the foundation for much of modern health and fitness media. His passion for physical fitness was ignited when he discovered German gymnasiums in St. Louis as a young man. This led him to become a personal trainer and eventually start the highly successful magazine Physical Culture. McFadden's magazine revolutionized the publishing industry with its personal and confessional style, setting the stage for modern reality television and personal branding techniques. His radical health and fitness ideas, such as intermittent fasting, raw food diets, and the importance of exercise, were ahead of their time. McFadden also had a controversial personal life, including his obsession with eugenics and his involvement in a utopian community. While McFadden's popularity declined in his later years, his influence on health and fitness, as well as media, continues to be seen today.
The Impact of McFadden's Magazines on Health and Fitness
McFadden's magazines, especially Physical Culture, became a platform for spreading his health and fitness philosophy. He emphasized the ideas that Americans ate too much and didn't exercise enough. Through his magazines, McFadden promoted plant-based diets, portion control, and physical exercise as solutions to health issues. His personal voice and use of before-and-after photos of himself and readers made the magazines popular. McFadden's magazines had a significant impact on shaping the genre of confessional and personal narrative publications, which is still evident in today's media landscape.
McFadden's Influence on Publishing and Media
McFadden's publishing empire extended beyond health and fitness magazines. He started True Story, a confessional magazine where readers sent in their own dramatic stories. This confessional style became wildly popular and laid the foundation for modern reality television and personal branding. McFadden also employed influential media personalities of the time, such as Walter Winchell and Ed Sullivan, further expanding his reach. His influence can even be seen in later media figures, with Joe Weider and Charles Atlas carrying on his legacy in the bodybuilding industry.
McFadden's Political Aspirations and Controversial Views
McFadden's political aspirations led him to run for public office, but his unconventional ideas and controversial views hindered his success. He aligned himself briefly with the Democratic Party, but later became more aligned with Republican beliefs. His support for autocrats like Mussolini and his opposition to germs theory and vaccinations clashed with the changing times and public sentiment. Ultimately, his political career failed, and he faded into obscurity, no longer in step with contemporary America.
The Legacy of Bernard McFadden
Although Bernard McFadden was forgotten in later years, his ideas and influence still resonate in today's health and fitness world. Many of his concepts, such as intermittent fasting, exercise routines, and the emphasis on whole foods, have made a resurgence. McFadden's unapologetic personal branding and confessional approach laid the groundwork for reality television and autobiographical storytelling in media. While his methods may have been eccentric and some outcomes dubious, McFadden's lasting legacy lies in his pioneering efforts to bring health and fitness to the forefront of American culture.
The topic of health and fitness has long been a popular one for magazines, and in most recent times, for blogs and Instagram accounts. But what these modern publishers and influencers probably don't realize is that they're standing on the shoulders of an ambitious eccentric who laid the foundation for much of modern American media: Bernarr Macfadden.
My guest today is Mark Adams, who wrote a biography of this proto fitness guru called Mr. America: How Muscular Millionaire Bernarr Macfadden Transformed the Nation Through Sex, Salad, and the Ultimate Starvation Diet. Mark and I begin our conversation with how Macfadden discovered a passion for health and fitness as a young man and failed at his attempt to become a personal trainer, despite coining the motto "Weakness is a crime; don't be a criminal." We then discuss how Macfadden went on to start the highly successful magazine, Physical Culture, and then an entire publishing empire, which pioneered many of the confessional, first-person, personal branding techniques still used today. Mark shares the tenets of Macfadden's sometimes sound, sometimes wacky health philosophy, including his advocacy of fasting, and what happened when Mark tried out some of Macfadden's protocols on himself. Mark and I then delve into how Macfadden founded a utopian community in the New Jersey suburbs, was convicted of obscenity charges, trained fascist cadets for Mussolini, and ran for U.S. senator on a physical fitness platform. We end our conversation with why Macfadden was forgotten, and yet had a lasting effect on the world of health and fitness, as well as media as a whole.