The Missing Piece of Stoicism: Why Kindness is Strength | Donald Robertson
Feb 13, 2025
auto_awesome
In this engaging discussion, Donald Robertson, an expert on Stoicism, challenges the common misconceptions surrounding the philosophy by emphasizing that true strength lies in kindness and compassion. He explains how Marcus Aurelius viewed anger as weakness, asserting that empathy is a core tenet of Stoic thought. The conversation also dives into the emotional mastery that Stoicism promotes, and how it resonates with early Christian ethics, illuminating the vital connection between compassion and philosophical strength.
True Stoicism emphasizes that authentic strength is derived from kindness and compassion towards all humanity, including adversaries.
Modern misinterpretations of Stoicism overlook its core message of emotional resilience through healthy expression rather than suppression of feelings.
Deep dives
The True Essence of Stoicism
Stoicism emphasizes the importance of brotherly love and compassion towards all humanity, rather than promoting a violent or aggressive outlook. Marcus Aurelius, while discussing virtues in his meditations, highlights the significance of cultivating natural affection for others, including those considered adversaries. Despite being at war with certain groups, he champions the idea of seeing them as kin rather than enemies, thus embodying the essence of cosmopolitanism. This perspective illustrates that true strength lies in kindness and understanding, particularly in the face of conflict.
Misunderstanding Stoicism in Modern Context
Modern interpretations of Stoicism often miss its true purpose, reducing it to a notion of being unemotional or suppressing feelings. Psychological research indicates that such emotional suppression can lead to fragility and mental illness, contradicting the original Stoic principles that promote emotional resilience. Ancient Stoicism, which served as a foundation for cognitive therapy, encourages individuals to manage and express emotions in a healthy way. The shift in terminology over the years has led to a skewed perception of Stoicism, painting it as detached when it is, in fact, about fostering social virtue and emotional well-being.
The Role of Natural Affection in Stoic Ethics
Natural affection and familial bonds are central themes in Stoic ethics, promoting a sense of care for others, particularly children. Stoics like Epictetus acknowledge that it is human nature to develop affection and engage compassionately with the world around us. They argue that such affection should not only be reserved for close relations but should extend to humanity as a whole, reflecting a god-like compassion. This broader vision of care underlines Stoicism's alignment with Christian ethics, sharing common values of love, kindness, and community interconnectedness.
Modern Stoicism often focuses on self-control and resilience, but what if we’ve overlooked its most important lesson?
True Stoicism is about strength through compassion. Marcus Aurelius believed that anger is weakness and that true power comes from brotherly love and justice. Yet today, Stoicism is often misrepresented as cold, emotionless, and distant.