Nancy Sherman, a Georgetown philosophy professor, explores how Stoicism can aid modern soldiers in healing both physically and mentally. She discusses the emotional resilience and personal growth Stoic principles can foster, particularly for those facing trauma. Sherman examines the misconceptions around emotions in Stoicism, the complexities of moral injury, and the challenges soldiers face when reintegrating into civilian life. Her insights highlight the importance of empathy in healing and shed light on stories from her works like 'Afterwar'.
Stoicism provides modern soldiers with tools to manage emotional responses and foster mental resilience amidst the challenges of warfare.
Addressing moral injuries through empathy and honest dialogue is crucial for the healing process of veterans re-integrating into civilian life.
Deep dives
Understanding Stoicism
Stoicism is an ancient philosophy emphasizing the importance of virtue, self-sufficiency, and rational control over one's emotions. It suggests that true happiness is not contingent upon external circumstances but is derived from one's internal character and reasoning. The Stoics believed that emotions, particularly negative ones, can be seen as disturbances that distract individuals from their rational goals, ultimately arguing that maintaining a perspective where emotions do not lead to attachment or dependency is crucial for mental resilience. By fostering self-discipline and focusing on what can be controlled, Stoicism provides a framework for individuals to navigate life's challenges more effectively.
Application of Stoicism in Military Life
The application of stoic principles in military contexts offers soldiers tools for coping with the challenges of warfare and the aftermath of combat. Nancy Sherman highlights the essence of Stoicism in helping soldiers deal with severe experiences, such as the loss of comrades and the psychological impacts of war, including PTSD. The philosophy empowers individuals to separate their identities from external physical harm, instilling a sense of control over their mental states during difficult circumstances. Through the teachings of figures like Epictetus, soldiers learn to navigate feelings of helplessness by focusing on their internal responses rather than external events.
Moral Injuries and Recovery
Moral injuries, a concept less frequently discussed than PTSD, refer to the psychological damage that soldiers experience when their actions or inactions during warfare conflict with their moral beliefs. Sherman emphasizes the importance of acknowledging these moral injuries, as they can lead to feelings of guilt, shame, and anguish, which are crucial to the healing process. Addressing moral injuries involves creating spaces for empathy, self-reflection, and honest dialogue about traumatic experiences in order to facilitate recovery. Efforts to heal moral wounds must consider both clinical approaches and community support to foster understanding and re-establish bonds for reintegrating veterans into civilian life.
Navigating Emotion and Loss
Stoicism encourages a thoughtful approach to emotions, especially in the face of significant loss and trauma. Soldiers often struggle to express their grief publicly but may find solace in sharing their emotions with trusted comrades privately. This acknowledgment of vulnerability while wearing a stoic facade reflects the balance soldiers must find in navigating their emotions, guiding them towards healing while maintaining their roles. A moderated view of Stoicism recognizes the importance of processing loss constructively, where grieving becomes a necessary part of recovery, rather than denying the emotional reality of their experiences.
We've talked about Stoicism before on the Art of Manliness. From eminent men like Seneca and Marcus Aurelius, the Romans heartily embraced the philosophy. My guest today wrote a book about how Stoicism can help our modern soldiers. Nancy Sherman is a professor of philosophy at Georgetown, and on today's show we talk about healing not only physical wounds, but mental ones too with this ancient way of thinking.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode