In this episode, the hosts discuss fat burners and their effectiveness. They reference a recent study that showed a commercially available thermogenesis fat burner seemed to have some effect, but the extent of its impact on fat loss is uncertain. They also explore the ingredients in fat burners, individual variation in energy expenditure, and the effects of caffeine. The hosts share personal experiences with fat burners during preparation for competitions. They discuss other fat burners on the market and the broader data on this class of supplements.
Fat burners slightly increase resting energy expenditure but do not significantly affect weight or body composition.
Caffeine has small or trivial effects on weight loss, fat mass, and BMI.
The effectiveness of green tea and capsaicin supplements for significant weight loss is limited.
Deep dives
Fat Burners and Weight Loss
The podcast episode discusses the effectiveness of fat burners for weight loss. The study analyzed the impact of a multi-ingredient fat burner on resting energy expenditure and body composition. It found that the fat burner slightly increased resting energy expenditure, but did not significantly affect weight, fat mass, or body fat percentage. The study highlighted the importance of overall calorie intake and exercise when considering fat burners for weight loss.
Caffeine as a Fat Burner
The podcast episode also explored the role of caffeine as a fat burner. While caffeine has been linked to increased energy expenditure and may have some appetite suppressant effects, the overall evidence regarding its effectiveness for weight loss is not convincing. Studies have shown small or trivial effects on weight loss, fat mass, and BMI. The podcast emphasized the need for considering the overall context of caffeine intake and not relying solely on it as a fat burning solution.
Effectiveness of Green Tea and Capsaicin
The podcast briefly mentioned the potential effects of green tea and capsaicin supplements on weight loss. However, the magnitude of their impact appears to be very small. While they may have minor effects on weight, BMI, or waist circumference, the overall evidence suggests that their effectiveness for significant weight loss is limited. The podcast emphasized that any potential benefits of these supplements should be considered in the context of a comprehensive weight loss strategy.
Limited impact of metabolic adaptation in long-term weight loss success
Metabolic adaptation, which refers to the decrease in metabolic rate during weight loss, is not a determining factor in predicting long-term weight loss success. While it may require slight adjustments in calorie intake or longer dieting periods, the impact of metabolic adaptation on weight loss goals is relatively small, typically a few hundred calories. Other factors such as behavioral, genetic, and environmental aspects have a much larger influence on long-term weight loss outcomes.
Ineffectiveness of fat burners and thermogenic supplements
Fat burners and thermogenic supplements have shown limited benefits in reducing body mass and improving cardiometabolic health. Various studies, including meta-analyses, have concluded that these supplements, including prescription weight loss drugs, do not significantly impact weight loss outcomes. The magnitude of effect is often small, and the overall data does not support the widespread effectiveness of fat burners. Lifestyle habits, consistency with diet and exercise, and behavior modification are more crucial factors for successful weight loss and maintenance.
Happy Holidays cultists! We sincerely thank you all for joining us every week to explore the history, science and culture of the iron and we look forward to doing it more in 2024! In this episode, Omar and Helms discuss fat burners: supplements that supposedly enhance fat loss either by increasing energy expenditure and/or by blunting hunger and reducing energy intake. You’ve probably seen dozens marketed over the years if you’ve been around the fitness industry for any decent length of time, but do they actually work? In this episode we discuss the science of fat burners. A recent study coming out of none other than Dr. Grant Tinsley’s lab showed that a commercially available thermogenesis fat burner did seem to do something, but how meaningful it was and whether it actually would lead to fat loss is up for debate. Finally, we discuss where the data lies broadly on this whole class of supplements.
00:00 Not off to the best start… Fuelling conspiracy theories and reviewing reviews
11:31 Getting into the topic of fat burners
Siedler 2023 Chronic Thermogenic Dietary Supplement Consumption: Effects on Body Composition, Anthropometrics, and Metabolism https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38004200/
22:05 The ingredients in the “matrix” and individual variation in energy expenditure
33:02 The curious Eric Helms case: REE, BF%, and fat burners during prep
41:00 Other fat burners on the market and the effects of caffeine
Tabrizi 2019 The effects of caffeine intake on weight loss: a systematic review and dose-response meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30335479/
Clark 2021 Comparing effectiveness of fat burners and thermogenic supplements to diet and exercise for weight loss and cardiometabolic health: Systematic review and meta-analysis https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33427571/