Nick Fishwick, a former senior member of the British Foreign Office, and Dave Pitts, a former senior CIA executive specializing in clandestine operations, dive into the complex realities of modern warfare. They discuss Russia's mastery of gray zone tactics, which allow them to meddle internationally without triggering direct conflict. The conversation also explores how Western nations are evolving their strategies in response, analyzing the varied U.S. foreign policy approaches under different administrations and the importance of intelligence sharing amid geopolitical tensions.
Russia's gray zone operations manipulate ambiguity to damage adversaries without triggering formal military responses, complicating international relations.
Recent shifts in Russian clandestine tactics demonstrate an evolving threat that necessitates enhanced intelligence collaboration among Western allies.
Deep dives
Understanding Gray Zone Operations
Gray zone operations refer to the unpredictable sphere between peace and war where nations work to promote their interests while undermining those of their adversaries, often without provoking a military response. This creates a tactical advantage, allowing states like Russia to damage opponents while remaining below the threshold that would trigger open conflict. As noted, recent reports indicate that Russia has intensified its sabotage efforts to exert pressure on the U.S. and its allies regarding Ukraine. Such operations exploit ambiguity, allowing for covert actions that can be construed as hostile without formal declarations of war.
Evolution of Russian Interference Tactics
The nature of Russian clandestine operations has evolved significantly over the years, transitioning from traditional espionage to a broader array of aggressive tactics aimed at undermining Western societies. Historical examples of Russian interference, such as the assassination of Litvinenko and the poisoning of Skripal, illustrate a shift towards using lethal measures and public destabilization initiatives. Current Russian intelligence operations now favor collaborations with criminal organizations and low-profile actors to execute sabotage-related activities, making detection by Western intelligence much more challenging. This shift highlights the increasing complexity of Russia's approach in the gray zone, demonstrating a willingness to disrupt political stability through unconventional means.
The Complexity of Great Power Competition
The current geopolitical landscape reflects heightened great power competition, significantly characterized by Russia's ongoing aggression and the challenges presented to U.S. national security. With the resurgence of Russia and the rising influence of China, there are more threats to the U.S. than at any time in history, complicating diplomatic interactions and strategies. The podcast discusses the importance of understanding that negotiations with Russia are fundamentally intertwined with its long-term objectives of damaging NATO and American influence in Europe. This reality suggests that diplomatic efforts are unlikely to alter Moscow's goals, prompting the need for thorough vigilance and a reevaluation of responses to Russia’s actions.
Assessing Future Threats and Responses
Looking ahead, the unpredictability of Putin's strategies poses risks that may require shifts in how Western intelligence agencies collaborate to counter Russian aggression effectively. Continuing intelligence sharing among allies, particularly within frameworks like the Five Eyes, remains critical to maintaining a unified front against threats stemming from Russian gray zone operations. Potential changes in U.S. foreign policy could further complicate these alliances, impacting the willingness of nations to cooperate on intelligence matters. The consensus is that while the current circumstances are precarious, concerted efforts and adaptability among allies will be essential in navigating these challenges and deterring future hostile actions from Russia.
Despite efforts by U.S. President Donald Trump to warm U.S. relations with Moscow amid negotiations for Russia to end its war in Ukraine, Russian sabotage operations, active measures and Gray Zone activities are continuing around the world. Moscow has mastered the art of engaging in operations that push right up to the edge of war, without really crossing that that line, or have they? The Cipher Brief talks with former Senior Member of the British Foreign Office Nick Fishwick and former senior CIA Executive Dave Pitts – who spent the bulk of his time at the Agency working in clandestine operations – about this new reality – that what we are seeing is really “war by a new name”.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode