Episode 208: What Happens When a Pastor Sets Out to Prove Complementarianism? ft. Terran Williams
Oct 5, 2023
auto_awesome
Terran Williams, author of How God Sees Women and What's So Amazing About Scripture, joins the podcast to discuss their journey from complementarianism to egalitarianism. They examine flawed aspects of complementarianism, emphasize the importance of women's voices in church leadership, explore stories where Jesus interacts with women, and address challenges in navigating conversations about complementarianism. They offer advice on dealing with closed-minded pastors and the fear of gaslighting.
Evaluating complementarianism's theological and exegetical weaknesses led a former pastor to embrace egalitarianism.
Taryn Williams' book on gender equality impacted a denomination within the Assemblies of God in South Africa, prompting a shift in perspective and ordinations of women.
Powerful stories of women in ministry and leadership highlight their vital role in the flourishing of the church.
Deep dives
Taryn Williams' Journey in Reevaluating Complementarianism
Taryn Williams, a former complementarian pastor, shares his personal journey of reevaluating the complementarian doctrine in his book 'How God Sees Women'. He describes how his original beliefs were challenged as he studied Scripture and engaged with scholarship on both sides of the argument. Through his research, he came to the realization that complementarianism was lacking in theological and exegetical strength, particularly when considering the synthesis of all biblical passages. This revelation led him to embrace egalitarianism and advocate for women's leadership and equality in the church. His experiences highlight the importance of intellectual curiosity, humility, and open-mindedness in reevaluating long-held beliefs.
The Impact of Taryn Williams' Book on Church Movements
Taryn Williams' book, 'How God Sees Women', has had a significant impact on church movements worldwide. One powerful example is a denomination within the Assemblies of God in South Africa, where the new denominational leader embraced egalitarianism after reading the book. He then ordered copies for all pastors in the denomination and conducted ordinations of women in front of Taryn Williams. This shift in perspective highlights the potential for change within the church and the importance of promoting theological understanding that supports women's giftings and leadership.
Encouraging Stories of Women in Ministry
Despite challenges and opposition, numerous powerful stories are emerging of women in ministry and leadership roles. Vibrant congregations are being led by women church planters who go to great lengths to spread the gospel, even in patriarchal cultures. These women plant churches and care for their congregations, bringing about significant growth and impact. These stories serve as a reminder that women have essential roles to play in God's kingdom, and their gifts and leadership are vital for the flourishing of the church.
Challenges and Decision-Making for Complementarian Churches
In complementarian churches, it can be challenging for individuals who have changed their perspective on gender roles. Approaching church leaders and initiating conversations about reevaluating complementarian beliefs can be met with resistance and misunderstanding. While some individuals choose to remain in such churches and continue advocating for change, others may decide to seek out egalitarian churches where their beliefs align more closely. Ultimately, the decision to stay and advocate or leave and seek a different church depends on individual circumstances, available options, and personal convictions.
The Journey Towards Better Theology
As conversations about gender roles and equality continue, it is crucial for the church to pursue better theology that aligns with the values of equality, mutual partnership, and flourishing for men and women. The goal should be seeking a deep understanding of Scripture and the Great Commission, focusing on unity, collaboration, and embracing the diverse gifts and callings of both men and women in leadership. By promoting a more accurate understanding of biblical teachings on gender, the church can move towards a more inclusive and empowering environment for all believers.