Nicholas Eberstadt, a prominent political economist and expert on demographics, joins Kanishk Tharoor to discuss a looming global challenge: the age of depopulation. They delve into the dramatic drop in fertility rates, particularly in places like India and Europe. Eberstadt argues that personal choices, rather than policies, drive these declines. They explore how governments can better manage the implications of shrinking populations, touching on migration, automation, and the balance between individual freedom and societal needs in an evolving world.
The world is entering an era of depopulation marked by unprecedented declines in fertility rates across diverse regions, necessitating new societal adaptations.
Individual choices rather than economic pressures drive fertility rate declines, highlighting the need for nuanced understanding in formulating effective policy responses.
Deep dives
Demographic Shifts and Their Implications
Global fertility rates are declining at an unprecedented rate, with many regions, including historically high-fertility areas, experiencing significant drops, making sub-replacement levels a pressing concern. For instance, Mexico City has seen birth rates drop to below one child per woman, a trend echoed in cities like Kolkata and nations such as Thailand. This widespread decline suggests a fundamental shift away from the previous population explosion towards a state of depopulation, which could begin affecting global demographics as early as 2053. The implications of this demographic transformation are far-reaching, influencing not only societal structures but also the economic and geopolitical landscapes globally.
Factors Influencing Low Fertility
The decline in fertility rates is predominantly influenced by individual preferences rather than external factors like economic constraints or environmental issues. People across various cultures and countries are opting for smaller family sizes based on personal volition, indicating a more complex understanding of fertility choices. For instance, Myanmar, a low-income nation, exhibits below-replacement fertility not due to poverty but due to parental decisions influenced by social progress and changing values. While economic factors, education, and access to contraception correlate with declining birth rates, they do not provide a complete explanation for this global phenomenon.
Adapting to an Aging and Shrinking Population
Societies face significant challenges as they adapt to the realities of a shrinking and aging population, necessitating changes in government and corporate strategies. Traditional models of financing social programs, relying on a high ratio of current workers to retirees, will become unsustainable as the population pyramid shifts. Countries must begin to implement forward-thinking policies focused on individual savings and community cooperation to manage this transition effectively. Embracing technological advancements and promoting immigration can provide necessary buffers against workforce shortages, helping societies to thrive even in a context of depopulation.
Over the past century, the world’s population has exploded—surging from around one and a half billion people in 1900 to roughly eight billion today. But according to the political economist Nicholas Eberstadt, that chapter of human history is over, and a new era, which he calls the age of depopulation, has begun.
Eberstadt is the Henry Wendt Chair in Political Economy at the American Enterprise Institute and has written extensively on demographics, economic development, and international security. In a recent essay for Foreign Affairs, Eberstadt argued that plummeting fertility rates everywhere from the United States and Europe to India and China point to a new demographic order—one that will transform societies, economies, and geopolitics.
Eberstadt spoke with senior editor Kanishk Tharoor about what is driving today’s population decline, why policy cannot reverse it, and how governments can reckon with a shrinking world.