Scott Carmichael is an author focused on espionage, and Jim Popkin has written extensively about intelligence activities. They dive into the intriguing case of Ana Montes, a U.S. defense analyst turned Cuban spy. The conversation reveals the surprising motivations behind her betrayal and explores the complexities of her double life. They discuss the relentless investigation into her actions and the peculiarities surrounding her detachment during arrest. Listeners gain insight into the intricate world of spies in America and the personal conflicts that arise in such dangerous territories.
Ana Montes served as a U.S. defense intelligence analyst for 17 years, sharing classified information with Cuba, driven by ideological beliefs.
The investigation into Montes exposed significant challenges in identifying insider threats, particularly when biases led to overlooking female suspects.
Deep dives
The Role of the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA)
The Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) operates as a pivotal entity in the U.S. military intelligence community, providing essential information about foreign nations. Unlike the CIA, which is often recognized for covert operations, the DIA focuses primarily on military intelligence for the Department of Defense. In response to the increasing threat of espionage within its ranks, the DIA established its internal counterintelligence unit in 1988, emphasizing its commitment to safeguarding national security. Scott Carmichael, who worked in the DIA for 26 years, highlights how they monitor thousands of personnel globally to detect various espionage activities against the U.S.
The Espionage of Ana Montes
Ana Montes, a senior analyst within the DIA, conducted espionage for Cuba over 17 years, largely motivated by her ideological beliefs against U.S. foreign policy. Throughout her tenure, she successfully memorized and relayed classified intelligence back to her handlers, showcasing her diligence and espionage techniques. Montes's background included a family that favored Puerto Rican independence, influencing her strong anti-American stance and ultimately leading to her recruitment by Cuban intelligence. Her actions highlight the dangers posed by spies who operate based on conviction rather than financial gain, posing significant threats to national security.
Counterintelligence Efforts and Challenges
The investigative efforts into Montes's activities shed light on the complexities of counterintelligence work, particularly in recognizing potential threats among personnel. Scott Carmichael faced significant challenges in convincing the FBI to consider Montes as a suspect, as initial investigations were focused on male agents. Despite being dismissed multiple times, Carmichael persisted in compiling evidence that ultimately led the FBI to monitor her actions closely. This persistence paid off when surveillance caught her making suspicious calls to numbers linked to Cuban intelligence, which validated Carmichael's concerns and led to a broader investigation.
Consequences of Espionage
Montes was arrested shortly after the events of September 11, 2001, a period when national security concerns were heightened. She pled guilty to conspiracy to commit espionage and was sentenced to 25 years, significantly impacting her life and the lives of those she betrayed. The information she leaked was classified and sensitive, including the identities of CIA agents in Havana, leading to the potential threat to their safety. Upon her release in 2023, Montes expressed a desire to reintegrate into society while grappling with her past and the implications of her actions.
Sign up for Criminal Plus to get behind-the-scenes bonus episodes of Criminal, ad-free listening of all of our shows, members-only merch, and more. Learn more and sign up here.