
Plain English with Derek Thompson Plain English BEST OF: What Experts Really Think About Smartphones and Mental Health
48 snips
Dec 30, 2025 Join Jay Van Bavel, a psychology and neuroscience professor at NYU, as he dives into the nuanced relationship between smartphones and mental health. He discusses the motivation behind conducting an expert survey and the surprising consensus that social media affects sleep and attention. Jay highlights the need for balanced research on established harms versus emerging claims and examines whether delaying phone use until high school could be beneficial. With insights on social media's polarizing nature and its impact on mental health discussions, this conversation is enlightening!
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Social Media Distorts Expert Consensus
- Public debate on social media often amplifies extreme voices and misrepresents expert nuance.
- Jay Van Bavel created a large expert survey to surface the underlying, more nuanced consensus among researchers.
How The Delphi Panel Was Built
- Van Bavel and collaborators started by curating claims from Jonathan Haidt's book and invited critics to shape the survey.
- They built the expert panel by posting on listservs and personally inviting researchers to participate.
Consensus Grows Around Established Findings
- Experts reached near-universal agreement on long-studied links like sleep deprivation harming mental health.
- Claims newer to the literature needed nuance and caveats before broad expert agreement emerged.




