Rachel Winkler, a partner at Nixon Peabody Law Firm and former DHS policy expert, delves into the complexities of immigration law and mass deportation. She discusses the legal challenges undocumented immigrants face, including the impact of potential policy changes and the intricacies of detention laws. Winkler highlights the role of mixed-status households and the human costs of mass deportation. The conversation reveals the necessity for a balance between securing borders and recognizing the contributions of immigrant labor, while also touching on the historical context of deportation practices.
The estimated number of undocumented immigrants in the U.S. is between 11 and 14 million, highlighting ongoing demographic shifts and complexities in immigration.
Legal pathways for changing immigration status exist but are hindered by backlogged courts and complicated processes, impacting many undocumented individuals' futures.
Potential policy changes under a new administration could significantly impact immigration enforcement and the rights of individuals facing expedited deportations.
Deep dives
Overview of Undocumented Immigrant Population
The estimated number of undocumented immigrants in the United States ranges between 11 and 14 million, with notable demographic shifts occurring over time. While there was a decline in this population from 2007 to 2019, numbers have reportedly increased by about 500,000 annually since 2020. Approximately 70% of households with unauthorized immigrants include lawful immigrants or U.S.-born residents, complicating the immigration landscape. Mexico remains the largest source of undocumented immigrants, followed by Central American countries such as Guatemala, El Salvador, and Honduras, with an increasing number from India.
Legal Pathways and Challenges for Undocumented Immigrants
There are various legal pathways for undocumented immigrants to change their status, but many face significant obstacles due to backlogged immigration courts and complex processes. Those with existing deportation orders, whether issued long ago or recently, may have opportunities to seek waivers or relief based on changed circumstances such as family ties to U.S. citizens or lawful residents. Notably, those with removal orders often find themselves in limbo, awaiting action that may not be forthcoming if their home countries refuse to accept them. The immigration system's inefficiencies create a challenging environment for individuals seeking legal status, leading many to avoid initiating formal proceedings.
Impact of Presidential Policies on Immigration Enforcement
With a change in administration, there is potential for significant shifts in immigration enforcement policies, particularly related to expedited removals and prosecutorial discretion. The incoming administration could prioritize the removal of individuals with pending deportation orders by eliminating policies that allow for discretion based on sympathetic circumstances. This could streamline the deportation process for many, particularly those with criminal convictions, but would also raise concerns about the treatment and rights of individuals facing swift removal without fair legal processes. The completion of these policies hinges on effective collaboration among various federal and local law enforcement agencies.
Role of Sanctuary Cities and Legal Challenges
Sanctuary cities present complex challenges for immigration enforcement as they often limit cooperation with federal authorities on undocumented individuals’ cases, particularly regarding low-level offenses. While these jurisdictions may refuse to share information with ICE, they sometimes do cooperate regarding serious crimes, which can create variances in enforcement outcomes. Legal disputes regarding the extent of federal authority over immigration at the state level continue to arise, with the Supreme Court yet to definitively weigh in. This ongoing tension illustrates the delicate balance between local governance and federal immigration enforcement efforts.
The Need for Comprehensive Immigration Reform
The discussion surrounding immigration reform highlights the necessity for a thoughtful and structured approach to address the complexities of legalization and border security. Business leaders and advocates stress the importance of maintaining a reliable workforce, often reliant on immigrant labor, to ensure economic stability and growth. Many argue for the establishment of legal pathways for workers while enhancing national security measures to manage the flow of undocumented immigrants. Comprehensive immigration reform is seen as vital to America's global competitiveness and the ability to attract talent, countering the politicization that has historically hindered progress in this area.
Jim talks with lawyer and former DHS policy person Rachel Winkler about Trump's promise to carry out a large-scale deportation operation. They discuss estimates of undocumented immigrants in the U.S., mixed-status households & the aging undocumented population, the legal standing of an undocumented immigrant, types of undocumented immigrants, the process for pending deportation orders, potential policy changes, prosecutorial discretion, practical constraints on mass deportations, private detention companies, cooperation with Mexico, the Alien Enemies Act & the Insurrection Act, balancing secure borders with the need for immigrants, and much more.
Episode Transcript
Rachel Winkler is a member of the Cross-Border Risks team. Utilizing experience working with federal law enforcement partners and professionals at DHS, Rachel’s practice focuses on U.S. immigration benefits, compliance, and status defense; visa sponsorship and eligibility; removal defense; forced labor supply chain compliance with Section 307; and international criminal investigations. She also handles customs and I-9 verification issues. Her clients include individuals (including those with white-collar convictions), entities, and startups across various industries including tech and entertainment.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
