Gaslighting by Google at the Creator Summit? Morgan McBride Shares Her Experience
Nov 13, 2024
auto_awesome
Morgan McBride, a thriving DIY and crafting content creator, shares her rollercoaster journey from being a Google Success Story to facing drastic traffic drops after algorithm updates. She candidly discusses the complexities small publishers face and the emotional toll of navigating Google's changes. The conversation touches on the disconnect between creators and Google, the need for better communication, and the importance of diversifying content strategies. Morgan emphasizes resilience and adapting to new opportunities in the ever-evolving digital landscape.
Content creators are facing significant challenges as drastic Google updates can lead to severe drops in traffic and revenue overnight.
Many attendees of the Google Creator Summit felt a disconnect with Google's representatives, perceiving their responses as dismissive of real struggles faced by creators.
In response to declining traffic, creators are diversifying their strategies by focusing more on video content and exploring alternative platforms.
Deep dives
Impact of Google Updates on Traffic and Revenue
The podcast discusses the significant impact of Google's updates on website traffic and revenue, particularly highlighting a drastic drop in performance for certain sites. After being featured as a Google Success Story, a dramatic 75% reduction in traffic and revenue occurred overnight following a core update. This drastic decline reflects the uncertainty that many content creators face regarding Google's algorithms and the reality that previous successes do not guarantee future stability. Creators have expressed feelings of betrayal as their previously recognized quality content suddenly became undervalued.
Personal Experiences from the Google Web Summit
Attendees at the Google Web Summit shared their emotional responses to the event, which was characterized by a somber and unsettling atmosphere. Experiences varied, with some expressing disbelief at the lack of understanding exhibited by Google representatives regarding the struggles of individual publishers. Conversations revealed a disconnect between Google's engineers and the actual experiences of content creators, leading to frustrations about the perceived ineffectiveness of Google's support systems. The event's tone was often described as depressing, reflecting the significant challenges faced by content creators who felt disregarded.
Disillusionment with Google’s Messaging
Critiques emerged regarding Google's communication style and messaging, especially concerning the intent behind algorithm updates. Attendees expressed skepticism towards Google's claims that they prioritize helpful content, with many feeling insulted by being told to simply create better content. The response from Google representatives, particularly from high-level officials, was described as dismissive of the real struggles faced by creators. The sense of being gaslit was prevalent, as creators were left questioning the legitimacy of their own hard work and the authenticity of Google's reassurances.
Shifts in Content Creation Strategies
In light of declining traffic from Google, many creators are pivoting towards alternative strategies, including a greater focus on video content and diversification across platforms. Creators are exploring channels like Pinterest and Instagram to connect with audiences in varied ways, even as they continue to produce written content for blogs. The discussion highlights the necessity of adapting to audience preferences, particularly in the current digital landscape where video engagement is increasingly vital. It emphasizes that while traffic sources may fluctuate, the ability to evolve and meet audience needs is crucial for long-term success.
Finding Resilience Amidst Change
The episode conveys a message of resilience and encourages creators to adapt and innovate in the wake of challenges presented by Google updates. It underscores the importance of maintaining a positive mindset and fostering excitement about new projects, regardless of past disappointments. Creators are urged to focus on building identity and purpose beyond solely relying on Google for traffic generation. The overarching sentiment is to embrace change, support each other in the community, and continue pursuing passions in content creation with renewed determination.
This week, Jared Bauman sits down with Morgan McBride, a previously successful content creator who was first highlighted as a Google Success Story and then crushed by its HCU.
She was invited to the Google Creator Summit, but her experience and interview contrasts sharply with Jake Cain's, who also attended the event.
Morgan holds nothing back as she talks about growing her portfolio of websites, getting hit by the update, and everything that did (and didn't) happen at this special event for creators.
Ready to join a niche publishing mastermind, and hear from industry experts each week? Join the Niche Pursuits Community here: https://community.nichepursuits.com
Want a Faster and Easier Way to Build Internal Links? Get $15 off Link Whisper with Discount Code "Podcast" on the Checkout Screen: https://www.nichepursuits.com/linkwhisper