Philosopher's Zone

Sense, sensibility and the authentic self

Nov 27, 2024
Lucinda Holdforth, a Sydney-based author and speechwriter, critiques our modern obsession with authenticity, vulnerability, and empathy. She explores how these traits, while positive, can undermine rational public discourse. Delving into Jane Austen's insights, Holdforth contrasts reason with emotion, revealing the tension in leaders showcasing personal narratives. The discussion touches on the dangers of prioritizing feelings over facts in politics, especially during turbulent times, and warns against the seductive pull of conspiracy theories in a disillusioned society.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Feelings Over Facts

  • Contemporary discourse prioritizes feelings over facts, evident in phrases like "my truth" and "my lived experience".
  • Challenging feelings is now seen as attacking someone's identity, hindering productive discussions.
ANECDOTE

Sense and Sensibility

  • Jane Austen's Sense and Sensibility depicts two sisters, Eleanor (reason) and Marianne (emotion).
  • Initially, Marianne's passionate nature is charming, but she becomes selfish, while Eleanor prioritizes their community.
INSIGHT

Philosophical Parallels

  • Plato, like Marianne, championed idealized forms and a philosopher king, prioritizing emotions and a totalitarian system.
  • Aristotle, similar to Eleanor, focused on rhetoric, reason, and practicality, grounded in a factual world.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app