Johnathan Bi

Why Good People Make Terrible Leaders | Machiavelli's Ethics Explained

72 snips
Nov 28, 2025
Explore why virtuous individuals often struggle as leaders. Discover how Machiavelli uses Moses as a model for necessary evil and the importance of maintaining political order. Hear about the controversial idea that cruelty can be a tool for stability. Delve into Machiavelli's perspective on using religious authority as a means to justify harsh decisions. The discussion highlights the complex balance between political necessity and moral integrity, urging listeners to reconsider the nature of leadership and the sacrifices it demands.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
ANECDOTE

Moses As Machiavelli’s Model

  • Johnathan Bi tells how Machiavelli idolizes Moses as the model of a founder who 'enters into evil' to secure the law.
  • He recounts Exodus 32 and Moses' massacre and lie to justify establishing the Ten Commandments.
INSIGHT

Law Requires Arms To Be Enforced

  • Machiavelli distinguishes prophets from armed founders and claims law requires force to be enforced.
  • He argues Moses’ massacre taught the people a memorable lesson that enabled lasting law and order.
ANECDOTE

Did Moses Lie About God’s Command?

  • Johnathan Bi highlights scholarship suggesting Moses lied when he ordered the Levites to kill, claiming God commanded it.
  • He notes subsequent divine plague implies the massacre was Moses’ initiative, not God’s command.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app