AI-powered
podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
The "What is Money?" Show
A Logic of Violence | The Platonic Philosophy Series | Episode 1 (WiM202)
Aug 17, 2022
02:56:36
AI Summary
Highlights
AI Chapters
Episode notes
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
- Avoid extremes of dogmatism and relativism for a balanced worldview.
- Integrate contemplative and computational reasoning for deeper insights.
- Seek a synoptic integration of relative and absolute aspects of reality.
- Embrace dialogos for collective understanding beyond individual perspectives.
- Recognize the dangers of rejecting reason and transcendence leading to nihilism.
Deep dives
The Importance of Bitcoin Strategy in Building Wealth
Having a Bitcoin strategy and a trusted partner, like Swan Bitcoin, is crucial in navigating the financial landscape. Swan Private offers personalized guidance for high net worth individuals and businesses to build and preserve wealth with Bitcoin, ensuring direct access to expert advisors and US-regulated custodians.
Exploring the Dangers of Dogmatism and Relativism
Dogmatism and relativism can lead to dangerous extremes when pursued in isolation. Dogmatism can absolutize the relative, while relativism can make each perspective self-contained and incontrovertible. Schindler emphasizes the need to avoid both dogmatism and relativism by seeking a deeper integration that transcends these polarized approaches.
Connecting Contemplation and Computation in Reasoning
Plato's approach integrates contemplative and computational reasoning to seek deeper understanding beyond mere logical manipulation. The contemplative aspect of reason involves moving beyond formal systems to engage in self-correction and transcending perspectives. Schindler highlights the importance of balancing both contemplative wisdom and computational logic for richer insights.
Unveiling the Interconnectedness Between Relative and Absolute Realities
Plato delves into the intricate relationship between the relative and absolute aspects of reality, emphasizing a synoptic integration that binds the changing nature of the relative with the unchanging essence of the absolute. The constant search for the through line that unifies diverse elements reflects a deeper understanding of non-logical identity and the interconnectedness of all phenomena.
Dialogos: The Power of Multiple Perspectives
Plato's works delve into the essence of dialogos, where engaging in conversations with varied voices transcends individual perspectives. Through dialogical interactions, insights unreachable through monologues emerge, offering a deeper understanding collectively.
Adaptability and Organism-Environment Coupling
The podcast scrutinizes the concept of adaptivity, focusing on the interdependence between organisms and their environments. Emphasizing the ratio and religio in fit and proper connectivity, it elucidates that an organism's adaptivity extends beyond its individual traits or external surroundings.
Intellectual Impatience and Mythological Insights
The discussion navigates through modern cultural habits highlighting intellectual impatience and abstraction tendencies. It juxtaposes the trivialization of reason against a deeper understanding of the role of technology and politics in shaping societal dynamics.
Plato's Quest for Absolute Truth and Dialectical Reasoning
Delving into Plato's intent in employing dialogue-laden narratives, the episode explores the significance of synthesizing multiple perspectives to approach the concept of the good. It draws analogies between dialogical reasoning and network architecture principles, emphasizing the power of interconnected perspectives in logical reasoning and truth-seeking.
Thrasimachus Proposes a World of Personal Expression and Relativism
Thrasimachus, in the dialogue with Socrates, advocates for a worldview where he holds the power to shape reality without constraints from external factors. He views himself as a cartographer drawing on a blank canvas, emphasizing personal expression as the sole determinant of truth. This perspective echoes elements of romanticism and suggests a belief that reality is malleable based on individual interpretation.
Violence, Sophistry, and the Absence of the Good
The podcast delves into the link between violence and sophistic epistemology, highlighting how a rejection of reason and transcendence leads to nihilism. Thrasimachus' insistence on imposing his perspective symbolizes a self-contradictory desire for power, lacking a foundation in reality. The narrative explores the consequences of mistaking appearances for reality and the intrinsic connection between relativism, violence, and the absence of a commitment to universal good.
14.
The Great Unsolved Problem in Physics to Day, Is Conciliating Relativity With Quantum Mechanics
2min
36.
Aristotle's Foundation of Reason Is the Contentless Principle of Contradiction
6min
In this special edition series, I will be joined by multiple thinkers and philosophers to discuss Platonic and Neoplatonic philosophy. This ongoing series of conversations will focus on the nature of goodness, truth, justice, freedom, beauty, reason, and love. My first guest in this series is the eminent cognitive scientist and philosopher John Vervaeke, and we examine D.C. Schindler's masterpiece "Plato's Critique of Impure Reason: On Goodness and Truth in the Republic."
Be sure to check out Swan Private, the trusted Bitcoin financial services provider for high-net-worth individuals and businesses worldwide: https://www.swanprivate.com/breedlove
Guest
John's Twitter: https://twitter.com/vervaeke_john
Plato's Critique of Impure Reason: https://www.amazon.com/Platos-Critique-Impure-Reason-Goodness/dp/0813228247#:~:text=Plato's%20Critique%20of%20Impure%20Reason%20offers%20a%20dramatic%20interpretation%20of,real%20image%22%20of%20the%20good.
PODCAST
Podcast Website: https://whatismoneypodcast.com/
Apple Podcast: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-what-is-money-show/id1541404400 Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/25LPvm8EewBGyfQQ1abIsE?si=wgVuY16XR0io4NLNo0A11A&nd=1
RSS Feed: https://feeds.simplecast.com/MLdpYXYI
Transcript:
Outline
00:00:00 “What is Money?” Intro
00:00:08 Swan Private
00:01:37 Introducing the Book “Plato’s Critique of Impure Reason”
00:04:40 The Central Argument of the Book: Enriching Our Understanding of Reason
00:08:34 Ratio (Science and Rationality) and Religio (Connectedness and Religion)
00:11:22 Love as a Proper Proportioning in Service of the Whole
00:15:15 The Deeper Meaning of Reason: “Love for What Is Real”
00:18:09 A Return to the Contemplative, Non-Computational Account of Reason
00:30:15 The Elusive “I”: The Impossibility of Framing the Process of Framing
00:35:53 Theoria: To Contemplate, to Look in the Right Way, to Travel to See
00:40:22 Misology: The Total Abandonment of Reason
00:49:00 How Theory Shapes the Interpretation of Our Perceptions
00:55:45 The Absolute Simultaneously Transcends and Includes the Relative
01:09:15 The Inspiration of John’s Neologism “Transjective”
01:13:39 The Trivialization of Reason, Intellectual Impatience, and Hyperbolic Discounting
01:22:14 Watch “Hard Money with Natalie Brunell” From Swan Studios
01:23:00 Take Control of Your Healthcare with CrowdHealth
01:24:09 Printing Money Causes People to Lose Perspective on the Whole?
01:28:16 Intellectual Impatience, Misology, and Totalitarianism
01:34:10 “The Dictator Wins if He Can Make Everybody as Impulsive as Him”
01:38:22 The Significance of Plato and the Idea of “The Good”
01:45:44 The Good: The Unbreakable Promise of Intelligibility Always Tracking Reality
01:50:43 Science is Based on the Ongoing Faith that Reality is Intelligible
01:57:00 The Through-Line as the True-Line: Is There Universal Darwinism?
02:03:34 The Distortions of Our Present “Cultural Cognitive Grammar”
02:07:26 The Relationship Between the Dialectical and the Dialogical
02:16:48 The Degree of Dialogical Connection Increases Collective Intelligence
02:19:49 Entering Chapter 1: A Logic of Violence
02:30:48 Substituting Faithfulness to The Logos with Totalizing Knowledge Brings Violence
02:39:17 “Hitler Came to Power for A Reason”
02:46:38 Using “Flatland” to Analogize the Transcendence of The Good
02:56:28 “What is Money?” Outro
SOCIAL
Breedlove Twitter: https://twitter.com/Breedlove22
WiM? Twitter: https://twitter.com/WhatisMoneyShow
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/breedlove22/
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/breedlove_22/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@breedlove22?lang=en
All My Current Work: https://linktr.ee/breedlove22
WRITTEN WORK
Medium: https://breedlove22.medium.com/
Substack: https://breedlove22.substack.com/
WAYS TO CONTRIBUTE
Bitcoin: 3D1gfxKZKMtfWaD1bkwiR6JsDzu6e9bZQ7
Sats via Strike: https://strike.me/breedlove22
Sats via Tippin.me: https://tippin.me/@Breedlove22
Dollars via Paypal: https://www.paypal.com/paypalme/RBreedlove
Dollars via Venmo: https://venmo.com/code?user_id=1784359925317632528
The "What is Money?" Show Patreon Page: https://www.patreon.com/user?u=32843101&fan_landing=true
RECOMMENDED BUSINESSES
Swan Private guides high-net-worth individuals and businesses in all areas of Bitcoin strategy: https://www.swanprivate.com/breedlove
CrowdHealth offers an innovative health insurance model based on Bitcoin and community: https://www.joincrowdhealth.com/breedlove
Okcoin is an innovative and education-focused cryptoasset exchange platform—earn $50 in free Bitcoin by signing up at: https://okcoin.com/breedlove
Invest with a licensed Bitcoin advisor through DAIM: https://daimio.typeform.com/RobertBreedlove
Join Me At Bitcoin 2023, pre-order your tickets now (for a chance to win 10M sats, use discount code BREEDLOVE): https://b.tc/conference/2023
Automatic Recurring Bitcoin Buys and Withdrawals: https://www.swanbitcoin.com/breedlove/
Get the Snipd
podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered
Discover
highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any
moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share
& Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered
podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover
highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode