Beyond Perfection: Coaching for Excellence with Lewis Hatchett
Feb 14, 2025
auto_awesome
In this discussion, former professional cricketer and mindset coach Lewis Hatchett shares his insights on perfectionism in sports. He highlights the fine line between motivation and self-sabotage, revealing how the pursuit of flawless performance can lead to anxiety. Lewis introduces 'excellencism,' a mindset that encourages athletes to set realistic goals while embracing mistakes as growth opportunities. He also emphasizes the importance of emotional intelligence and supportive coaching environments in fostering resilience and adaptability among athletes.
The podcast addresses the dual impact of perfectionism on athletes, highlighting its potential to inspire high performance while also inducing anxiety and fear of failure.
Lewis Hatchett introduces the concept of Minimal Viable Performance (MVP), encouraging athletes to focus on reasonable goals to foster resilience and prevent discouragement.
The conversation emphasizes the significant role coaches play in shaping athletes' self-esteem and the necessity for supportive relationships that promote growth and embrace mistakes.
Deep dives
Free Coaching Development Evenings
Two free coach development evenings are being offered for rugby coaches to enhance their coaching skills. The first event takes place at Yatun RFC, near Bristol, on February 28th, followed by another in southwest London at Old Wimbledonians Warriors on March 11th. These informal gatherings aim to provide coaches with practical drills, tactics for attack and defense, and strategies for session planning. Attendees will also have the opportunity to engage in discussions and share ideas with fellow coaches, making this an excellent networking opportunity.
Understanding Perfectionism in Sports
Perfectionism, though often perceived positively, can be detrimental to athletes' performance and mindset. Experts discuss how setting unrealistically high standards can lead to a fear of failure, causing athletes to disengage when they fall short. The podcast highlights the nuanced view of perfectionism, emphasizing that while striving for high standards can motivate, it can also create undue pressure. An example is cited involving Tom Brady's remarkable 69% pass completion rate, which illustrates the importance of setting achievable performance metrics.
The Concept of Minimal Viable Performance (MVP)
The idea of Minimal Viable Performance (MVP) is introduced as a practical way for athletes to maintain motivation during training. Instead of aspiring for unattainable perfection, athletes are encouraged to focus on reasonable goals, assessing their success based on consistent efforts rather than flawless execution. This approach allows athletes to gauge progress while minimizing the emotional toll of perceived failures. Implementing MVP can foster a more resilient mindset, as athletes learn to celebrate incremental improvements rather than getting discouraged by missteps.
Excellencism: A Balanced Approach to Coaching
The model of excellencism is introduced as a healthier alternative to perfectionism, focusing on maintaining high performance standards without the overwhelming burden of perfectionist ideals. It encourages athletes to embrace their flaws while striving for improvement, which can boost morale and drive. Coaches are urged to adopt a mindset that rewards effort and progress rather than punishing mistakes, creating an environment conducive to personal growth. This method allows athletes to flourish in their sport while reducing anxiety associated with performance expectations.
The Impact of Coaching on Athletes' Mindsets
The podcast explores the significant influence that coaches have on athletes' perceptions of their own performance and motivation. It discusses how a coach's approach can either cultivate a fear of failure or promote a sense of agency among their players. Research is highlighted that assesses how athletes perceive their coaches' perfectionism, revealing that rigid expectations can diminish athletes’ self-esteem and willingness to take risks. Ultimately, the conversation emphasizes the importance of fostering positive coach-athlete relationships, where players feel supported and empowered to make mistakes and learn from them.
In this episode of the Rugby Coach Weekly Podcast, Dan Cottrell speaks with Lewis Hatchett—former professional cricketer, mindset coach, and creator of the MindStrong Sport app. They discuss perfectionism in sport, its benefits and drawbacks, and how it affects athletes and coaches.
Lewis shares his personal experiences with perfectionism, explaining how it can drive high performance but also lead to anxiety, self-doubt, and fear of failure. The conversation explores the impact of coaching environments, the role of perceived perfectionism, and how athletes can shift towards "excellencism"—striving for success without the pressure of unrealistic expectations.
Key topics include:
✅ How perfectionism impacts athletes and teams ✅ The psychological cost of chasing flawless performance ✅ Coaching strategies to build confidence, adaptability, and resilience ✅ How to help athletes embrace mistakes as part of growth ✅ Insights from Lewis’ research on coaching, perfectionism, and fear of failure
If you're a coach, athlete, or parent looking to understand the mindset behind elite performance, this episode offers practical advice and research-based insights. Lewis also shares how coaches can contribute to his ongoing research.
📩 Want to connect with Lewis? Find him at MindStrongSport.com or reach out via hello@lewishatchet.com.