Build systems are vital for efficient task automation and developer workflow streamlining.
Make's popularity stems from its simplicity and efficiency, but it has limitations like overly conservative rebuilding.
Diverse build systems for various languages foster innovation but pose compatibility challenges across projects.
Deep dives
Importance of Build Systems in Software Development
Build systems are crucial in automating tasks like compiling source files, running tests, and updating documentation, streamlining developer workflows. The simplicity and efficiency of build systems like make have made them popular choices in managing tasks efficiently. Make's incremental approach ensures that only necessary tasks are rerun, reducing unnecessary work and ensuring responsiveness in the development process.
Challenges and Limitations of Make Build System
Despite Make's popularity, it has limitations such as being overly conservative in determining when tasks need to be rebuilt based on timestamps. This can lead to unnecessary recompilations. Additionally, Make's simplistic programming language can become cumbersome for complex builds, especially with macros or large code bases. The lack of flexibility and scalability in handling large or parallel builds poses challenges for efficiency and maintenance.
Diversification and Specialization in Build Systems
The podcast delves into the plethora of build systems tailored to different languages, communities, and project requirements. Each community often opts to create its own build system optimized for specific needs. While this diversification fosters innovation and exploration in the build system design space, it also raises compatibility challenges when projects have dependencies across varied build systems. Efforts to create language-agnostic build systems face hurdles in maintaining deterministic and efficient builds across diverse project environments.
Transitioning from Jenga to Dune Build System
Jenga Street was using both the Jenga and Okamole build systems internally, causing a need to introduce a smoother process. This led to the development of Dune, initially a simple and fast tool without incremental rebuild support. Over time, Dune improved with incremental capabilities, eventually surpassing Jenga in features, including cloud build support.
Evolution of Build Systems and Incremental Computation
The evolution of build systems involves integrating them with development environments for enhanced productivity. This includes editor integration for quick error feedback and seamless code navigation. The discussion extends to scientific computation's need for incremental processing and how modern ideas aim to streamline development workflows by automating tasks and optimizing performance.
Most software engineers only think about their build system when it breaks; and yet, this often unloved piece of software forms the backbone of every serious project. This week, Ron has a conversation with Andrey Mokhov about build systems, from the venerable Make to Bazel and beyond. Andrey has a lot of experience in this field, including significant contributions to the replacement for the Glasgow Haskell Compiler’s Make-based system and Build Systems à la carte, a paper that untangles the complex ecosystem of existing build systems. Ron and Andrey muse on questions like why every language community seems to have its own purpose-built system and, closer to home, where Andrey and the rest of the build systems team at Jane Street are focusing their efforts.
You can find the transcript for this episode along with links to related work on our website.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode