Legal experts Josie Duffy Rice, Kathrina Szymborski Wolfkot, and writer Kyle Barry discuss relying on state courts and state constitutional law in addressing criminal legal system challenges. They delve into the hubris and hackery of Judge Aileen Cannon's decision on the Trump classified documents case, highlighting the promises and challenges of state courts in enforcing rights against extreme punishments and shaping federal law.
Federal courts' failure to address prison abuses highlights the need for state court intervention on Eighth Amendment issues.
State courts can lead national criminal justice reforms by setting precedents for accountability and compassion in sentencing and treatment.
State Supreme Courts are using state constitutions to push beyond U.S. Supreme Court limits, focusing on excessive punishments and improving prison conditions.
Deep dives
Lack of Federal Court Enforcement
The Supreme Court's failure to enforce constitutional rights, such as the Eighth Amendment protections against extreme sentences and prison conditions, has left a void in addressing abusive practices in prisons. Cases where individuals have endured years of solitary confinement without exercise or suffered torture-like conditions have been dismissed by federal courts, often citing qualified immunity. The lack of federal court intervention in such cases contributes to the perpetuation of systemic human rights violations in prisons.
Potential Impact of State Court Action
State courts taking a more assertive role in challenging excessive sentences and demanding humane treatment for incarcerated individuals could have a transformative national impact. As criminal law practices originate and evolve at the state and local levels, heightened scrutiny and intervention by state courts could set precedents that influence broader criminal justice reforms. By shaping a culture of accountability and compassion at the state level, significant strides towards addressing abuse and disparity in the criminal justice system are achievable.
Addressing Systemic Injustice
With the majority of criminal cases occurring in state courts and the vast majority of incarcerated individuals under state custody, the potential ripple effect of progressive state court actions is substantial. Tackling prevalent abuses like solitary confinement, sexual assaults, and lack of mental health care behind bars requires a shift towards more compassionate and rights-focused perspectives. By emphasizing the human impact of incarceration and the essential need for humane treatment, state courts hold the key to rectifying systemic injustices within the criminal justice system.
State Courts Leading the Way in Departing from Federal Sentencing Guidelines
State Supreme Courts have been increasingly invoking state constitutions to exceed the limitations set by the U.S. Supreme Court in terms of excessive punishments. Examples include cases where state courts struck down life without parole sentences for minor offenses while the U.S. Supreme Court upheld similar extreme punishments. This trend is particularly evident in protecting the rights of young individuals by challenging the most severe sentences allowed by federal law.
Role of State Courts in Extending Constitutional Protections to Prison Conditions
State courts are not only focusing on excessive sentencing but are also expanding protections in prison conditions using unique state constitutional provisions. Cases in Washington and Oregon exemplify courts going beyond federal standards to ensure humane treatment behind bars. By enforcing a state-by-state strategy and leveraging state constitutional rights, state courts aim to strengthen the Eighth Amendment and promote more humane conditions for incarcerated individuals.
Kate and Leah attempt to wrap their heads around Aileen Cannon’s bonkers decision on the Trump classified documents case. Then, Leah talks with Josie Duffy Rice, Kathrina Szymborski Wolfkot, and Kyle Barry about the promises and challenges of relying on state courts and state constitutional law to address the criminal legal system. Check out Kyle’s piece on the subject here.
Get tickets for STRICT SCRUTINY LIVE – The Bad Decisions Tour 2025!
