Eric A. Moyen and John Thelin, experts in higher education, dive into the fascinating history of college sports in the U.S. They explore how collegiate athletics evolved from student-led competitions to a major influencer on university identity. The duo discusses the symbiotic relationship between sports and academia, the tensions of commercialization, and the impact of desegregation. They also highlight the financial challenges facing today’s athletic programs and question the sustainability of this unique American institution.
Collegiate sports in the U.S. illustrate a unique symbiotic relationship with higher education, reflecting cultural and institutional evolution over time.
The historical significance of the Harvard-Yale crew meet in 1852 sparked student engagement in athletics, significantly influencing student identity and community spirit.
Media's escalation of college sports popularity and infrastructure coincided with shifts in governance, impacting student participation and maintaining academic integrity.
Deep dives
The Unique Landscape of Collegiate Sports in America
Collegiate sports in the United States have developed a unique identity distinct from other nations, reflecting broader educational and societal trends. Unlike institutions in other countries, American universities have established highly engaging collegiate sports systems that generate substantial attention and revenue. This relationship is illustrated by the historical evolution of college sports, which closely aligns with the growth and transformation of American higher education itself. The intertwining of student culture with athletics has led to a distinctive collegiate experience that is often prioritized over academic pursuits, demonstrating how sports can reflect and shape the university experience.
The Historical Significance of Early Athletic Events
The first intercollegiate sporting event, the Harvard-Yale crew meet in 1852, marks a seminal moment in the history of college athletics, showcasing the early integration of student autonomy and competitive spirit. This event sparked student interest in organized athletics, which evolved from literature and debating clubs to physical competitions that fostered community and camaraderie among students. Notably, the spectacle of this early competition was fueled by corporate sponsorships, foreshadowing the commercialization of college sports that would continue to grow over time. The legacy of these early competitions laid the foundation for the complex relationship between collegiate athletics, institutional branding, and student identity.
The Role of Media in Popularizing College Sports
Media has played a pivotal role in amplifying the popularity of college sports throughout American history. Beginning in the late 19th century, newspapers competed for readership by featuring in-depth coverage of significant college athletic events, thereby elevating the profile of teams and drawing public interest. The emergence of large stadiums capable of accommodating thousands of spectators coincided with this media frenzy, further solidifying college football's status as a key aspect of American culture. The interaction between media coverage and athletic events continues to shape public perception and support for college sports today.
The Shift in Athletic Governance and Integration
The governance of college athletics has seen a significant transition from student-led initiatives to faculty and administrative control, somewhat eroding the participatory role of students over time. Early sports were predominantly organized and managed by students, which fostered a strong sense of community; however, as football grew in popularity, pressures arose for faculty to regulate athletes’ attendance and academic performance. This led to the establishment of athletic conferences, such as the Big Ten, resulting in top-down governance that aimed to maintain academic integrity amidst growing athletic commercialism. As a consequence, the dynamic between athletics and academics transformed, reflecting broader shifts in higher education.
The Impact of Title IX and Evolving Gender Roles in Sports
Title IX's passage marked a transformative shift for women's sports in American higher education, promoting equal opportunities for female athletes and challenging institutional resistance based on financial concerns. Initially focused on academics, Title IX catalyzed a significant expansion of women's sports, leading to increased visibility and investment, despite slow implementation. The chapter of historical comparison between female athletes such as Chris von Salza and Katie Ledecky illustrates the dramatic evolution of opportunities within collegiate athletics over time. This landmark legislation not only broadened female participation but also reshaped the landscape of college sports in a way that mirrored broader social changes regarding gender equality.
Many college professors like to remind each other that no other nation on earth has the system of collegiate sports that has developed in the United States, one in which the mishaps of a mediocre football team attract much more attention than what goes on in classrooms, labs, and libraries–and yes, I am thinking of the University of Virginia. These professors love to quote Cornell President Andrew Dickson White refusing to allow the Cornell football team to travel to a game with Michigan: “I will not permit thirty men to travel four hundred miles to agitate a bag of wind.” They remember that the University of Chicago had a football team and even a stadium, until President Robert Hutchins killed the program, declaring it an “infernal nuisance.”
But they’re less likely to know that it was that same Andrew Dickson White who nourished Cornell intercollegiate athletics, financially supporting the Cornell crew team so that they could beat Harvard and Yale. And professors are even less likely to contemplate an awful historical truth, that college sports have always enjoyed a symbiotic relationship to the university that hosts them, and that they have grown and changed in more or less the same way that the American university has grown and changed. Far from being a peripheral accident of history, college sports reveal important insights into American higher education.
Such is the argument of my guests Eric A. Moyen and John Thelin. Eric A. Moyen is a professor of higher education leadership and the Assistant Vice President for Student Success at Mississippi State University. John R. Thelin is the University Research Professor Emeritus of the history of higher education and public policy at the University of Kentucky. Both of them have written numerous books on both American higher education and college sports. Now they have co-written College Sports: A History.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode