Is Executive Functioning Real? 20 years of ADHD research says... maybe?
Jan 13, 2025
auto_awesome
The discussion delves into whether executive functioning is a real construct or simply misunderstood. Historical research is critiqued, connecting impulsivity and cognitive processes in ADHD. A meta-analysis involving thousands of participants highlights individual differences in executive function experiences. The validity of assessment tools for measuring executive function is also examined, sparking debate in the psychological community. Personal insights and neurodiversity in ADHD experiences offer a refreshing perspective on the evolving research landscape.
26:28
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
Recent research challenges the assumption that executive functioning deficits are inherent to ADHD, revealing a complex relationship that requires broader support strategies.
The distinction between executive function tasks and measures highlights the need for precise definitions and improved methodologies to better assess ADHD-related challenges.
Deep dives
Misunderstanding Executive Functioning in ADHD
There is a common misconception that executive functioning is an inherent part of ADHD, but research indicates that this is not entirely accurate. The latest DSM does not explicitly label executive functioning as a core feature of ADHD, instead highlighting inattention, hyperactivity, and impulsivity as the primary traits. While executive functioning difficulties are prevalent among individuals with ADHD, they are not universally present, suggesting a more complex relationship between the two. This distinction emphasizes the need to broaden support strategies to encompass other challenges faced by those with ADHD, rather than focusing solely on executive functioning deficits.
Validity of Executive Functioning Research
A meta-analysis examining executive functioning in ADHD included studies spanning over 20 years and revealed significant impairments in tasks related to response inhibition, working memory, and planning among individuals with ADHD. However, it also clarified that while executive function deficits are common, they are not exclusive or definitive of ADHD. This nuanced understanding suggests the need for more comprehensive measures and conceptualizations, as relying solely on executive functioning assessments does not provide a complete picture of ADHD experiences. The evolution of understanding over the years indicates the complexity of ADHD and the various factors influencing its manifestations.
Challenges in Measuring Executive Functioning
Recent research highlights the difficulty in interchangeably using executive functioning rating scales and performance tasks, as they often measure different constructs. One study found that while some tests predicted academic success, many existing assessments failed to capture the multifaceted nature of executive functioning. This disparity calls for more precise definitions and robust methodologies in measuring these constructs to improve diagnostic and support frameworks. As the field continues to explore these challenges, communication and understanding of individual differences in executive functioning among ADHD patients is essential for better-targeted interventions.
In this episode of The ADHD Skills Lab, Skye and I explore the critical question: is executive functioning even real or is it a poorly defined construct that's been misunderstood for decades?
Curious what's inside?
What the DSM says about executive function..
What's the difference between an executive function task vs. executive function measure?
Some ADHD'ers may not struggle with executive dysfunction at all.
CTA: If this is you, let us know! I have follow-up questions!
Thanks for being here! Until next time, Sarah Russell (Podcast Producer)
3. Join Our Focused Balanced Days Coaching Program
If you’re an overwhelmed professional who’s been late diagnosed with ADHD and wants research-based, practical strategies, send me a message and tell me a little about your profession and struggles, and I’ll be in touch! — Click Here
4. Work with me Privately
If you’d like to work directly with me to build your engine and create meaningful change fast... send me a message and tell me a little about your profession and struggles, and I’ll get you all the details! — Click Here