Ep. 84 Hype vs. Reality: Tom Goodwin on Fixing What’s Broken in Advertising

In this episode of the AdTechGod Pod, I’m joined by Tom Goodwin for a no-holds-barred conversation about the gap between marketing hype and real consumer experiences.

We dive into the current state of advertising from the pitfalls of performance obsession to the urgent need for brand building and creative reinvestment. Tom shares his take on AI’s growing role, why consumer sentiment around ads matters more than we admit, and how over-reliance on metrics can misguide strategy. His message is clear: the future belongs to brands that balance loyalty with results.

Takeaways

• Tom Goodwin's journey into advertising was accidental and driven by curiosity.
• There is a significant disconnect between marketing promises and consumer experiences.
• Brand building is becoming increasingly important in a world of abundance.
• Modern advertising has become overly focused on metrics and short-term results.
• AI in advertising may not deliver the emotional connection needed for brand loyalty.
• Consumer attitudes towards advertising have shifted to a disdainful view.
• The need for creative investment in advertising is critical for long-term success.
• Balancing brand and performance is essential for CMOs today.
• Metrics can distract from the true value of brand building.
• The time scale for brand loyalty is often much longer than immediate conversions.

Chapters

00:00 Introduction to Tom Goodwin and His Journey

03:01 The Disconnect in Modern Advertising

05:49 Brand Building vs. Performance Marketing

08:58 The Evolution of Marketing Strategies

12:05 The Role of AI in Advertising

14:55 Consumer Experience and Advertising Impact

17:49 The Need for Creative Investment

21:07 Balancing Brand and Performance

23:55 The Role of Metrics in Advertising

27:03 Consumer Attitudes Towards Advertising

30:10 The Future of Advertising Strategies

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices