UP348 The Squeezed Middle - The Valuation Question
Oct 17, 2023
auto_awesome
In this episode, Ben Wells and Andrew Umbers discuss the impact of strategic decisions on commercial income and capital value in professional sports. They explore the challenges faced by organizations in the middle market, the potential of aggregation in the sports industry, the promise and challenges of OTT media delivery, investing in sports and centralized platforms, data management and sponsor insights, and the implications of the American sports ownership model.
English sports properties spend only 1.7% of revenue on marketing, highlighting the disparity with US sports that spend 11.9%, calling for a change in governance and decision-making processes within the sports industry.
Sports organizations in the 'squeeze middle' face challenges such as underdeveloped commercial strategies and lack of centralized decision-making, emphasizing the need to adopt new commercial models, focus on long-term value, and invest in customer relationships to unlock revenue streams.
Aggregation and collaboration within the sports industry can create a richer proposition for broadcasters and sponsors, increasing overall value, requiring a shift in mindset towards a more collaborative approach.
Deep dives
The Importance of Commercial Income and Capital Value in Professional Sports
This podcast episode explores the impact of strategic choices on the commercial income and capital value of sports teams, leagues, and federations. The guests, Ben Wells and Andrew Umbers, highlight the disparity in marketing spending between US and English sports properties. While US sports spend 11.9% of revenue on marketing, English sports properties only spend 1.7%. They argue that a change in the governance and decision-making processes within the sports industry is necessary to adapt to the current landscape. The focus should be on long-term institutional value and investing in customer relationships rather than short-term sales.
The Challenges of the Squeeze Middle
The podcast delves into the concept of the 'squeeze middle,' referring to the majority of sports organizations that fall below the top-tier teams and leagues. These organizations face challenges such as underdeveloped commercial strategies, fragmented ecosystems, and a lack of centralized decision-making. The hosts and guests discuss the need for these organizations to adopt new commercial models, consider long-term value, and invest in customer relationships. They argue that by doing so, these organizations can improve their sustainability and unlock revenue streams, even without relying solely on match attendance or traditional sponsorship.
The Potential for Change and Transformation in Sports
The podcast explores potential solutions and opportunities for sports organizations in the squeeze middle. The guests suggest adopting strategies used by successful sports entities, such as centralizing back-office functions, creating aligned commercial strategies across leagues and clubs, and developing direct-to-consumer propositions. They emphasize the importance of data acquisition and analysis, as well as the need for long-term thinking, considering the engagement of fans on a personal level. The episode concludes by discussing potential financing options, including private equity and long-term capital, to support the transformation and growth of these organizations.
The Value of Aggregation and Collaboration in Sports
In this podcast episode, the speaker discusses the importance of aggregation and collaboration within the sports industry. With limited financial resources, clubs and organizations need to find ways to work together and achieve uniformity in their operations. By aggregating their resources and leveraging their collective power, they can create a much richer proposition for broadcasters and sponsors, ultimately increasing their overall value. This requires a shift in mindset and a more collaborative approach, understanding that giving up something for the greater good can lead to long-term benefits.
Maximizing the Potential of Sports Assets through Data
Another key point highlighted in the podcast is the untapped potential of sports organizations' assets, particularly through data. By understanding and utilizing data effectively, organizations can gain valuable insights about their fan base and engage with them in more targeted ways. Successful examples include the launch of volleyball TV's OTT platform, which engaged with 800 million people, and FIBA's use of data to increase impressions and engagements during the basketball World Cup. Proper data management and a shift in mindset about the value of fans as users can lead to increased revenues and investor interest, positioning sports organizations as more than just event management businesses.
This is part of our Squeezed Middle series on the strategic options available to the people running professional sport. The focus in this episode is the impact of those choices on the commercial income and capital value of sports teams, leagues and federations. Our guests are Ben Wells and Andrew Umbers. Ben is CEO of PTI Digital, the strategy and technology consultancy. Andrew is co-founder and partner of Oakwell Sports Advisory, the leading strategic and financial advisor in sports and sports technology. Andrew was formerly MD at Credit Suisse and more recently, he served as Chairman at Leeds United.
You can hear the previous episodes in the Squeezed Middle series by searching Unofficial Partner in Apple, Spotify or your favourite podcast app.
What is the Squeezed Middle? There is a small global elite of sports rights holders which are doing just fine. Billions of dollars in media revenue chases must-see content, from the NFL in the US, Premier League in England, the IPL in India through to the major quadrennial extravaganzas such as Olympics and World Cups. Likewise, there are clubs and institutions in the lower reaches of the sporting pyramid for whom not much has changed and who cut their cloth according to the local demand for traditional revenue generators such as sponsorship, match day tickets and merchandise. It's the middle of the market where much of the pain is being felt. The situation was described in a recent essay by our guest Ben Wells: 'Economic crises tend to cause money to move in one of two ways: to quality or to price. Those in the middle, who are not able to compete on either front, are squeezed.
In the last 12 months, not one major Olympic NGB was able to sign a primary sponsor, with the biggest deal of the year – British Cycling’s tier-two sponsorship with Shell – bringing significant amounts of criticism. In parallel Müller ended its long-running main sponsorship of UK Athletics after seven years. UK Athletics is currently teetering on the brink of bankruptcy.
This isn’t a situation unique to athletics. Headlines in rugby, cricket and the second and third tiers of football report of similar tales of woe – the result of unsustainable commercial models – trying to grow revenues in a business built around live events, which are limited by number and venue capacity and whose cost-bases are rising with rampant inflation – are the norm."
Unofficial Partner is the leading podcast for the business of sport. A mix of entertaining and thought provoking conversations with a who's who of the global industry. To join our community of listeners, sign up to the weekly UP Newsletter and follow us on Twitter and TikTok at @UnofficialPartner