The Commentary Magazine Podcast Is Immigration Policy Hurting Trump Now?
21 snips
Jan 16, 2026 
Eliana Johnson, a journalist with deep insights into national politics, joins Seth Mandel, a senior editor at Commentary Magazine, to discuss Trump's immigration policies and their impact on his approval ratings. They highlight how Trump's once-strong stance on immigration is now a liability, particularly amid poor economic sentiment. Eliana sheds light on local dynamics in Minneapolis, while the panel critiques the disconnection between Trump’s confrontational style and voter preferences, arguing that economic issues are paramount in shaping public opinion.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Trump's Immigration Brand Is Slipping
- Trump's approval is weak on specific policy areas even when overall numbers seem stable.
- His brand on immigration is eroding as serious enforcement now polls poorly, even among independents.
Economy Drives Voter Sentiment
- Economic perception now drives broader approval more than immigration.
- Seth Mandel warns Trump's proposed fixes trend left and won't restore confidence or solve affordability.
Tariffs Undermine Cost-Of-Living Claims
- Tariffs are politically visible and act like a consumer tax, hurting Trump's message on lowering prices.
- John Podhoretz argues tariffs are a core reason voters feel costs aren't falling.