Inside Exit Five: How We Doubled Community Growth in Under a Year (with Matt Carnevale)

#233: Inside Exit Five | In this episode, Matt Carnevale (Head of Community at Exit Five) joins the team at Circle to break down how we’ve doubled Exit Five community membership and boosted engagement—all by treating Exit Five like a product. He shares our playbook: audience growth, engagement systems, how we use member feedback to shape what we build, and why “curate, don’t create” has been key to scaling. If you’re running (or joining) a B2B community, this is how you make it work.

Matt covers:

• Why we think of community like a product, not just a channel
• How Exit Five grew community membership over 100% in under a year
• The systems we use to drive 40% monthly active user engagement
• The power of “tripwires,” onboarding, and member matchmaking
• How feedback loops shape what we build

Timestamps

• (00:00) - – Intro to Matt
• (04:03) - – Exit Five’s approach to community
• (06:33) - – What it means to treat community like a product
• (10:33) - – Why audience is the foundation of community growth
• (13:33) - – How Exit Five builds and converts audience from LinkedIn
• (16:33) - – Using content tripwires to drive signups
• (18:33) - – Offers that work: Why we use a 7-day free trial
• (21:33) - – How Exit Five got started as a paid community
• (24:33) - – The product mindset: build, test, iterate
• (28:37) - – Using member feedback to drive product decisions
• (30:37) - – Real example: member matchmaking feature
• (32:37) - – Promoting new community features like product launches
• (35:37) - – How we drive 40% monthly active usage
• (37:37) - – The value of member-led events and how we do them
• (40:37) - – Other plays: tagging experts, matchmaking, onboarding
• (43:37) - – Why self-promo was hurting our community and what changed when we cut it
• (45:37) - – Final takeaways + advice for small communities
• (49:37) - – Audience Q&A: re-engagement, matchmaking, content cadence

Send guest pitches and ideas to hi@exitfive.com
Join the Exit Five Newsletter here: https://www.exitfive.com/newsletter
Check out the Exit Five job board: https://jobs.exitfive.com/
Become an Exit Five member: https://community.exitfive.com/checkout/exit-five-membership

***

Today’s episode is brought to you by Grammarly.

Ever have one of those weeks where you spent more time replying to Slack and email than doing actual marketing work?

You’re not alone. The average marketing team spends 28+ hours a week just keeping up with comms.

That leads to burnout, frustration, and a whole lot of performative productivity that doesn’t actually move the needle.

AI-fluent marketing teams are changing that. Grammarly’s 2025 Productivity Shift Report shows how they’re using AI to:

– Cut down on back-and-forth

– Automate content, research, and reporting

– Eliminate busywork

– Make space for strategy

We’re marketers because we love crafting campaigns, driving revenue, and proving impact – not spending all day buried in messages.

Get the report and see how top teams are making AI actually useful.

Visit go.grammarly.com/exitfive to grab it.

***

Thanks to my friends at hatch.fm for producing this episode and handling all of the Exit Five podcast production.

• They give you unlimited podcast editing and strategy for your B2B podcast.
• Get unlimited podcast editing and on-demand strategy for one low monthly cost. Just upload your episode, and they take care of the rest.
• Visit hatch.fm to learn more