AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Journal's Unusual Policy
- James Heathers recounts a journal policy requiring peer review history sharing upon submission.
- He expresses disagreement but seeks Dan Quintana's perspective.
Paper Identity
- Dan Quintana points out the difficulty in defining when a paper becomes distinct from its revisions.
- Rewriting allows authors to claim a paper as different, regardless of its history.
Ineffective Policy
- Requesting peer review history won't stop journal shopping, as authors can lie.
- It's difficult to track previous submissions without clear identifiers.