46. Postmodern Philosophy and Beyond (w/ Stephen Hicks)
Feb 8, 2024
auto_awesome
Stephen Hicks, a distinguished professor of philosophy and author of Explaining Postmodernism, delves into the evolution of philosophical thought. He traces the shifts from premodern to modern and then to postmodern perspectives, revealing key historical influences like the Enlightenment. The conversation navigates the integration of valuable postmodern ideas into a post-postmodern framework, discussing healthy skepticism versus radical doubt. Hicks also critiques the stagnation of postmodern thought and advocates for a revival of Enlightenment values in contemporary discourse.
The transition from premodern to modern philosophy highlights a significant shift towards secular, empirical understandings of reality and knowledge.
Postmodernism serves as a critical response to Enlightenment ideals, challenging notions of objective truth and advocating for a more fragmented view of identity.
The concept of metamodernism emerges as a framework to synthesize insights from both modern and postmodern thought, promoting a hopeful pursuit of truth and meaning.
Deep dives
Understanding the Shift from Pre-Modern to Modern Philosophy
The transition from pre-modern to modern philosophy signifies a profound shift in metaphysical and epistemological frameworks. Pre-modern philosophy was deeply rooted in religious thought, often viewing reality through the lens of a dualistic metaphysical framework that prioritized a higher, spiritual world over the material one. The Enlightenment heralded a dramatic change, promoting a naturalistic view of the world that emphasized empirical observation and rational thought as the basis for knowledge. Key historical figures like Copernicus and Luther catalyzed this shift, leading to a more secular understanding of human nature and reality, enabling thinkers to explore the world independently of divine interpretation.
The Enlightenment's Embrace of Progress
Enlightenment thinkers fostered a narrative of progress, grounded in the belief that human beings could achieve greater knowledge and freedom through reason and scientific inquiry. This optimistic outlook was characterized by the conviction that advancements in science, politics, and ethics would lead to an improved quality of life. Movements advocating for equality, such as the abolition of slavery and women's rights, emerged during this time, reflecting the Enlightenment's belief in human agency and moral responsibility. Nevertheless, critics argue that this forward-looking narrative glossed over the complexities and darker aspects of modernity, including the devastating impacts of industrialization and the two World Wars.
Postmodernism as a Reaction to Modernity
Postmodernism arose as a critical response to the ideals of the Enlightenment, challenging its assumptions about truth, progress, and human nature. Prominent postmodern thinkers like Foucault and Derrida questioned the very foundations of modern philosophy, asserting that objective truth and universal narratives were illusions shaped by social constructs. This philosophical shift emphasized skepticism and anti-realism, leading to a more fragmented understanding of knowledge and identity. As a result, the postmodern perspective often views history as a series of power struggles, rejecting the optimism associated with Enlightenment progress.
Evaluating Postmodern Critiques
Despite the bleak outlook of postmodernism, some critiques hold merit, particularly in their emphasis on the complexities and shortcomings of modernity. Postmodern thinkers encourage a critical examination of established narratives and the recognition of marginalized voices, revealing how power dynamics shape knowledge and identity. This skeptical approach can foster a healthy culture of critique, prompting individuals to question authority and conventional wisdom. However, the pervasive pessimism of postmodernism ultimately risks paralyzing progress by undermining the possibility of objective truth and meaningful discourse.
Emerging from Postmodernism: A Path Forward
As society grapples with the consequences of both modern and postmodern thought, there is a growing recognition of the need to reinvigorate Enlightenment ideals while addressing postmodern critiques. The recent decline of postmodern dominance suggests a shift toward a more constructive dialogue, where new frameworks of thought can emerge. This 'metamodern' approach seeks to synthesize insights from both traditions, embracing skepticism without abandoning the pursuit of truth and meaning. By fostering a more integrated understanding of knowledge and human experience, it is possible to move beyond mere deconstruction toward a more hopeful and actionable vision for the future.
Stephen Hicks, a professor of philosophy and author of Explaining Postmodernism, joins me to discuss the transformation of worldviews from the premodern to the modern and from the modern to the postmodern. After his incisive overview of these dramatic shifts, we discuss what it might look like to integrate the genuinely positive contributions of postmodern thought, and consider where we are headed in a post-postmodern world.
0:00 Introduction
1:58 How to Trace Philosophical History
4:15 From Premodern to Modern
15:56 From Modern to Postmodern
34:07 How Do We Move Beyond the Modern and Postmodern while Integrating Their Strengths?
43:28 Relativizing the Critique
51:14 Living After Postmodernism
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode