The Edition: how twee triumphed, Graham Brady on Tory turmoil & celebrating pigs in blankets
Dec 5, 2024
auto_awesome
Gareth Roberts, author of "World War Twee," critiques the rise of twee culture in Britain, arguing it distracts from serious issues and leads to a tragic trivialization of society. Former 1922 Committee chair Graham Brady reflects on his influential role in British politics, discussing the challenges and absurdities he faced alongside party dynamics. Lastly, the conversation takes a festive turn as they debate the merits of pigs in blankets, sharing humorous anecdotes and creative culinary twists on this beloved holiday dish.
The rise of 'twee' culture reflects a troubling trend of excessive sentimentality in British society, raising concerns about its impact on serious discourse.
Graham Brady's reflections on his tenure reveal insights into the evolving dynamics of British politics during a tumultuous era for the Tory party.
Deep dives
The Rise of Twee in British Society
British society has become increasingly sentimental, a trend described as 'twee.' This phenomenon, noted by Gareth Roberts, suggests that the past decade has seen an upsurge in overly sweet and sentimental expressions in various aspects of life, from consumer products to politics. For instance, the branding of everyday items has shifted from straightforward to exaggerated storytelling, evident in yogurt packaging that emphasizes personal stories over simple, clear information. This transformation reflects a cultural shift towards a preference for softness and friendliness in public discourse, raising questions about the potential dangers of such sentimentality.
Social Media's Influence on Cultural Norms
The role of social media in shaping contemporary cultural norms has come under scrutiny, particularly regarding its tendency to promote anger as a dominant emotional response. Reports indicate that sensational or angry content garners more engagement due to the monetization of platforms, creating a cycle that prioritizes outrage. This short-form content consumption has led to a culture of immediate emotional reactions, leaving little room for deeper, more thoughtful discussions. As people increasingly crave longer, unfiltered dialogues, the contrast between quick emotional bursts and the need for substantial conversation becomes evident.
Authenticity in Public Discourse
The clash between the sweet, surface-level positivity of twee culture and the harsher realities of life breeds suspicion and frustration among the public. Insincerity in marketing and public discourse often leads to a lack of trust, particularly when faceless corporations project false intimacy. As individuals become adept at detecting inauthenticity, this disconnect feeds into broader societal anger. The perception of patronizing gestures or superficial friendliness can amplify feelings of resentment, prompting a deeper examination of how culture interacts with genuine emotions.
Cultural Consequences of Tweeness
The long-term cultural implications of a society steeped in twee may result in significant emotional backlashes as people face harsh realities. The rise of a trivialized, overly friendly public discourse can lead to a volatile atmosphere, where anger may simmer beneath the surface due to unaddressed grievances. As individuals encounter insincere communications from institutions, this may foster greater distrust and resentment. The accumulating disappointment from superficiality in public interactions signals a potential reckoning when these feelings inevitably surface in more substantive crises.
Gareth Roberts writes the cover article this week, arguing against what he sees as the hideous triviality of our times. ‘The British have lost their aversion to glutinous sentimentality,’ he declares. How did we get here, and who are the worst offenders? Gareth argues that the triumph of twee has left us unable to face serious things with seriousness. Could there be sinister consequences if we don’t take this more seriously? Gareth joined the podcast to make his case, alongside Josh Cohen, psychoanalyst and author of All The Rage (00:49).
Then: was Graham Brady the ‘kingmaker’ or the ‘kingslayer’ of the past Tory era?
The shadow cabinet member and Conservative M.P. Alex Burghart has reviewed Graham Brady’s new book Kingmaker: Secrets, Lies and the Truth about Five Prime Ministers in the books section of the magazine this week. Looking back on his time as chair of the influential 1922 Committee, Graham provides his reflections on what has been an historic, and often turbulent, period in British politics. Having now taken a seat in the Lords, Graham joins the podcast with The Spectator’s political editor, Katy Balls, to reveal what he really thought about that time in office and what his advice to his successor would be (16:07).
And finally: are pigs in blankets the best Christmas food?
It would seem so, according to The Spectator’s data editor Michael Simmons, who provides his notes on the festive treat in the magazine this week. His only gripe, as a proud Scot, is that they should really be called ‘kilted sausages’. He reveals that Brits are expected to eat a whopping 668 million of them over the Christmas season. Why are they so good, and how can you elevate your Christmas meal over the coming season? Michael joins the podcast alongside Martyn Lee, head of product at Yeo Valley and the former executive chef of Waitrose and Tesco. Plus, a guest appearance of pigs in blankets from The Spectator’s local pub, The Two Chairmen – will they pass Michael’s taste test? (26:58).
Hosted by William Moore and Lara Prendergast.
Produced by Patrick Gibbons, Oscar Edmondson, and Cindy Yu.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode