Andrea Zalin, an expert on BDSM and legal issues, returns to explore the controversial use of the "bogus BDSM defense" in sexual violence cases. They discuss how some attempt to disguise abuse as consensual kink, raising questions about consent and legal implications. The conversation touches on the intersection of race and the biases that complicate jury decisions. Zaldin emphasizes the importance of discerning genuine kink from coercion, advocating for better legal frameworks to protect victims and ensure justice.
The bogus BDSM defense exploits societal misconceptions about consent, complicating legal accountability for sexual violence and undermining justice for victims.
Intersectional factors, including race and socioeconomic status, significantly influence how the legal system perceives and adjudicates cases involving kink and BDSM practices.
Deep dives
The Mainstreaming and Misunderstanding of Kink
Kink and BDSM have gained significant visibility in recent years, but this increased awareness has also led to numerous myths and misconceptions. As kink becomes more present in mainstream media, the line between consensual kink and sexual assault has blurred, complicating public perceptions and legal interpretations. High-profile cases have shown how misunderstood concepts of consent can harm vulnerable individuals, as societal attitudes often fail to differentiate between consensual practices and violence. This lack of understanding poses serious risks, as individuals may exploit these misconceptions to justify abusive actions under the guise of kink.
The Bogus BDSM Defense and Its Implications
The bogus BDSM defense refers to the tactic of claiming consensual kink to mitigate accountability in cases of sexual violence. Research indicates that this defense can disproportionately benefit individuals from privileged backgrounds, while marginalized individuals often receive harsher scrutiny. The legal system struggles to adapt to these complications, lacking specialized knowledge about kink and BDSM practices that could inform judicial outcomes. Consequently, cases that invoke this defense can perpetuate biases and societal stigma, further complicating the pursuit of justice for victims.
Intersectionality and Bias in Legal Proceedings
Intersectional factors such as race, gender, and socioeconomic status significantly influence how cases involving kink are perceived in the legal system. Those who are marginalized, including individuals from communities of color or sex workers, face greater challenges in being believed and receiving fair treatment in court. This disparity underscores a systemic issue, exacerbating the difficulties victims encounter when seeking justice for sexual assault. The consistent patterns of bias reveal that, while kink practices have been normalized in society, societal and legal attitudes remain deeply unequal.
Challenges in Distinguishing Consent and Abuse
Determining the legitimacy of consensual kink or BDSM claims in legal contexts is complex and often fraught with uncertainty. Red flags can arise when practices associated with kink, such as choking or rough play, are not executed with proper negotiation and safety measures. Expert knowledge within the courtroom is crucial to differentiate between consensual practices and potential abuse, as uninformed judgments can have devastating consequences. Ultimately, the need for informed perspectives on sexual consent, especially in the context of kink, has never been more pressing in addressing sexual violence and promoting justice.
Was it consensual kink or sexual abuse? This question is at the heart of a growing number of legal cases. Unfortunately, people sometimes try to claim consensual kink as a cover for sexual violence, a trend my guest today refers to as “the bogus BDSM defense.” In this show, we’re going to dive into a few recent cases where the bogus BDSM defense has been deployed, as well as the signs that can help us to distinguish between consensual kink and sexual violence.
The Kinsey Institute at Indiana University has been a trusted source for scientific knowledge and research on critical issues in sexuality, gender, and reproduction for over 75 years. Learn about more research and upcoming events at kinseyinstitute.org or look for them on social media @kinseyinstitute.
***
Want to learn more about Sex and Psychology? Click here for previous articles or follow the blog on Facebook, Twitter, or Reddit to receive updates. You can also follow Dr. Lehmiller on YouTube and Instagram.
Listen and stream all episodes on Apple, Spotify, Google, or Amazon. Subscribe to automatically receive new episodes and please rate and review the podcast!
Credits: Precision Podcasting (Podcast editing) and Shutterstock/Florian (Music). Image created with Canva; photos used with permission of guest.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode