Deep Questions with Cal Newport Ep 383: Why Is Everyone Talking About “Against the Machine”? (w/ Tyler Austin Harper)
389 snips
Dec 15, 2025 
Tyler Austin Harper, a journalist and scholar, discusses Paul Kingsnorth's provocative book, "Against the Machine." They delve into Kingsnorth's critique of technology and its impact on culture and humanity. Tyler explains how Kingsnorth's deep disillusionment with sustainability led to a spiritual quest and a desire for limits in a tech-driven society. They explore the relevance of AI in sparking critiques of human relationships, emphasizing the need for balance in a world overwhelmed by technology. Harper offers insights into the public's growing resonance with these ideas.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
The Machine As A Cultural Frame
- Paul Kingsnorth frames modern society as a 'machine' that rejects limits and remakes nature and human nature through technology.
- This machine-centered view reconnects tech critique to grand cultural questions rather than fragmented policy or brain-focused frames.
From Radical Activist To Recluse Writer
- Tyler recounts Kingsnorth's background as a green radical who grew disillusioned when environmentalism embraced tech-based sustainability.
- That shift pushed him from activism toward writing, spiritual searching, and eventually a critique of pro-growth environmentalism.
Limits Are The Core Argument
- Kingsnorth argues modern culture privileges anti-limit growth across economics, identity, and technology.
- He sees many current debates as arguments about whether to defer to nature or to engineer it away.
