Dr. Bates Gill, Executive Director at the Asia Society Policy Institute, and Professor Rory Medcalf, Head of the National Security College, share their insights on the AUKUS pact. They discuss whether AUKUS can effectively counter China’s growing military influence in the Indo-Pacific. The conversation covers Australia’s substantial investment in nuclear submarines and the political complexities at play. They also examine China’s critical response, the role of the UK post-Brexit, and the implications for regional stability. Will AUKUS reshape defense strategies?
AUKUS represents a strategic shift in defense collaboration among the US, UK, and Australia to counter China's growing military influence in the Indo-Pacific.
The future effectiveness of AUKUS will hinge on sustained diplomacy to mitigate regional concerns and reassure nations about its stabilizing intentions.
Deep dives
Launch of AUKUS and Its Strategic Significance
The newly announced AUKUS security partnership between the United States, Australia, and the United Kingdom marks a significant shift in defense collaboration aimed at countering the growing military capabilities of China. Officially launched in March 2023, AUKUS will enable Australia to acquire nuclear-powered submarines, requiring a substantial investment forecasted to reach AUD 368 billion by the mid-2050s. This intergenerational commitment underscores a transformative approach to defense in the Indo-Pacific region, aiming not only to enhance military capabilities but also to foster deeper technological integration and industrial collaboration among the three nations. The alliance reflects a strategic response to the deteriorating security environment, characterized by China's increasing assertiveness and military advancements in recent years.
Australia's Defense Policy Shift
Australia's decision to pursue nuclear-powered submarines through AUKUS marks a dramatic evolution in its defense strategy, transitioning from a non-nuclear state to one poised to establish significant military capabilities. This shift is largely driven by concerns over China's expanding military influence and potential regional conflicts. The acquisition of nuclear submarines is seen as essential to enhancing Australia’s strategic weight in the Indo-Pacific, ultimately altering perceptions of its defensive posture. Despite bipartisan support for AUKUS, future Australian governments will need to maintain public and political backing amid evolving domestic sentiments concerning nuclear policies.
U.S. Perspective on AUKUS
From the U.S. viewpoint, the AUKUS partnership is a natural progression of its long-standing alliance with Australia, aimed at ensuring sustained American military presence in the Indo-Pacific. The U.S. has embraced AUKUS not only for its submarine collaboration but also for broader strategic goals, including potential logistics and technology sharing. This partnership enhances the U.S. ability to project power and counterbalance China's influence in the region, while also addressing logistical challenges that arise from its extensive supply lines. The partnership signals a commitment to deepening military cooperation and enhancing joint capabilities among close allies in response to rapidly shifting geopolitical dynamics.
Regional Reactions and Future Implications
The regional response to AUKUS has been mixed, reflecting diverse perspectives among Indo-Pacific nations. While countries like Japan and India view Australia's strengthened defense capabilities positively, concerns linger, particularly from China, which criticizes AUKUS as a threat to regional stability. Additionally, nations in Southeast Asia exhibit a range of attitudes, from support to skepticism, highlighting the complexity of regional diplomatic dynamics. Looking ahead, AUKUS has the potential to reshape the security architecture of the Indo-Pacific, but the three nations involved must engage in sustained diplomacy to reassure other countries that the partnership is aimed at stabilizing the region rather than escalating tensions.
Launched against the backdrop of a deteriorating security environment in the Indo-Pacific, will AUKUS prove an effective counterbalance to Chinese dominance in the region?
AUKUS, the tripartite deal between the US, the UK and Australia, caused considerable surprise and French consternation when it was announced in 2021. It involves acquiring a new fleet of nuclear-powered submarines for Australia, forecast to cost up to $368 billion between now and the mid-2050s, as well as aiming to boost defence capabilities, accelerate technological integration, and expand the industrial capacity of all three countries.
Beijing has branded the plan ‘a blatant act that constitutes serious nuclear proliferation risks, undermines the international non-proliferation system, fuels arms races, and hurts peace and stability in the region’.
In this episode, host Neil Melvin sits down with Dr Bates Gill, Executive Director of the Asia Society Policy Institute’s Centre for China Analysis, and Professor Rory Medcalf, Head of the National Security College (NSC) at the Australian National University, to discuss the future of AUKUS. Can the three countries deliver on their high ambitions? Can AUKUS reinforce deterrence in the Indo-Pacific and change the security and defence calculations of China? This episode of Global Security Briefing was made possible thanks to the generous support of the Carnegie Corporation of New York, as part of our project ‘Meeting the Challenge of China in the Indo-Pacific’.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode