Famous musicians like Charli XCX, Florence Welch, and Ed Sheeran discuss the pressure to make TikTok videos to promote their music, sparking a debate on the authenticity of their complaints, the dynamics between artists and fans, and the impact on lesser-known musicians.
Musicians on TikTok have been expressing frustration with their record labels, raising concerns about the demands placed on artists to engineer their own authenticity and virality on social media platforms.
Record labels are pressuring artists to create authentic TikTok content, blurring the line between real and manufactured authenticity, potentially damaging the connection between artists and fans while smaller artists without built-in audiences may struggle to meet these demands.
Deep dives
Musicians on TikTok: Forced Viral Promotions
Many musicians on TikTok have been posting videos that give off a supposed 'hostage situation' vibe, supposedly to promote their new music. These TikToks often have captions indicating that the record label is making them do this. Artists like Florence Welch, Charlie XCX, Ed Sheeran, and Halsey have all participated in this trend, expressing their frustration with their record labels. While some sympathize with the artists, others question whether these TikToks are just another marketing play to generate sympathy and virality. This trend also raises concerns about the demands placed on artists to engineer their own authenticity and virality on social media platforms.
The Influence and Complications of TikTok in the Music Industry
TikTok has become a powerful force in the music industry, with songs going viral and becoming popular solely because of the platform. It has even surpassed YouTube as a driver for Billboard chart success. The pressure to go viral on TikTok has led record labels to push their artists to create authentic TikTok content. However, this demand can create a fine line between real and manufactured authenticity, potentially damaging the connection between artists and fans. Additionally, smaller artists without built-in audiences may struggle to meet these demands, and some artists may not even want to engage on social media but are forced to due to label pressure.
Sympathy, Marketing, and the Power Dynamics in the Music Industry
The question of whether to feel sympathy for musicians caught up in these TikTok marketing strategies is complex. While some argue that it is part of the machinery of the music industry and that artists have the power to say no, others believe it raises important issues about record labels expecting artists to invite fans into their personal lives for the sake of promotion. There are concerns about the mental and emotional toll on artists, with some, like Ari Lennox and No Name, stating that they are taking breaks from music due to the demands of social media. Ultimately, it highlights the power dynamics within the music industry and the need for critical thinking about the demands placed on artists by record labels.
Over the past few months, musicians have been posting on TikTok about how their record labels are forcing them to make TikTok videos to promote their new music. On the show today, Rachelle and Madison look at what all these famous musicians like Charli XCX, Florence Welch, and Ed Sheeran are posting, why the music industry is so desperate for viral hits, and who we should feel sorry for in all of this.
This podcast is produced by Daniel Schroeder, Rachelle Hampton, and Madison Malone Kircher.