Risky Business with Nate Silver and Maria Konnikova

When You Come at the King: Holding Presidents to Account (with Elie Honig)

Sep 20, 2025
Elie Honig, a CNN senior legal analyst and former federal prosecutor, dives into the intricate history of special counsels in this engaging discussion. He highlights the political challenges these positions face, particularly during Trump’s presidency. Honig connects historical moments from Watergate to modern times, exploring the evolution of accountability. He also critiques overreaches like the Ken Starr investigation and proposes reforms for a more effective counsel office. A compelling blend of history and legal insight awaits!
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

What A Special Counsel Is

  • Special counsel is a DOJ-appointed prosecutor for conflicts or extraordinary circumstances, intended to shield investigations from political interference.
  • Elie Honig emphasizes the role is shaped by human motives and frailties more than by written rules.
ANECDOTE

Evidence Hid To Protect Investigations

  • Watergate prosecutors hid photocopies of key evidence at home fearing Nixon's goons would ransack offices.
  • Elie Honig parallels that to Mueller's team backing up files offsite fearing a similar takeover under Trump.
INSIGHT

Independent Counsel Law Backfired

  • The independent counsel law passed after Watergate repeatedly faced political resistance and ultimately expired in 1999.
  • Ken Starr's investigations into Clinton demonstrated how reauthorization risks backfiring on presidents who support it.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app