Rachel Swarns, a contributing writer for The New York Times, joins Letitia Clark, a clinical radiology professor and descendant of Edward Queen, along with Jeremy Alexander, who uncovers his enslaved family history. They discuss the painful legacy of slavery connected to the Jesuit Church in Maryland. The conversation highlights court cases where enslaved individuals sought freedom, personal stories of struggle, and the emotional journey of discovering familial ties to this dark past. Their insights reflect on ethics, family legacies, and the ongoing quest for justice.
The establishment of the Roman Catholic Church in America was deeply intertwined with slavery, showcasing the contradictory nature of its mission.
The legal struggles of enslaved individuals like the Mahoney brothers highlight the agency and resistance against oppressive systems within colonial America.
Deep dives
Foundation of Catholicism in America
In 1633, ships carrying Jesuit priests set sail from England to establish a Catholic colony in Maryland, marking the inception of the Roman Catholic Church in America. Upon arrival, the priests quickly began the colonization process, acquiring land and initiating tobacco plantations that relied heavily on enslaved labor from West Africa. This early Catholic establishment not only contributed to the growth of the Church but also participated in the troubling institution of slavery, as priests themselves engaged in slave sales and ownership. The duality of their mission to save souls while simultaneously exploiting human beings highlights the complex moral landscape of early American Catholicism.
The Struggle for Freedom
The case of Anne Joyce, a Black woman who was initially an indentured servant, showcases the precariousness of freedom in colonial Maryland. After her contract was maliciously destroyed by her enslaver, she was thrust into a life of slavery, perpetuating a cycle that affected her descendants for generations. Charles and Patrick Mahoney, her descendants, later filed a lawsuit for their freedom, representing a broader struggle seen throughout Maryland, where many enslaved individuals sought legal recognition as descendents of indentured servants. The legal battles of the Mahoney brothers reflect a nuanced attempt by enslaved individuals to assert their rights and dignity within a challenging legal framework.
Court Battles and the Legacy of Resistance
Between the 1770s and 1790s, numerous freedom suits were filed by enslaved individuals in Maryland, showcasing a remarkable instance of legal resistance against the system of slavery. Charles and Patrick Mahoney's case was particularly significant, as it represented hope for many others seeking emancipation, despite the immense risks associated with suing one's enslaver in an inherently biased judicial system. The brothers' battles culminate in a complicated legal struggle where, after years of litigation, one brother eventually wins his freedom, while his relatives' fates remain uncertain amid an unyielding slave system. This historical narrative serves to illuminate the overlooked agency of enslaved individuals in fighting for their rights in colonial America.
The 1838 Sale and Its Consequences
The 1838 sale of enslaved individuals by the Jesuits marked a pivotal moment of betrayal for those who believed in their protection from being sold. Harry Mahoney, a descendant of enslaved people, witnessed his family threatened as the Jesuits planned to sell hundreds of individuals under dire economic pressures. Despite his initial assurances of safety from the priests, the sale transpired, shattering families and instigating a mass relocation of enslaved people to severe conditions in the South. The subsequent sale not only devastated the Mahoney family but exemplified the moral dilemmas faced by those who espoused Catholic values while perpetuating slavery.
Sign up for Criminal Plus to get behind-the-scenes bonus episodes of Criminal, ad-free listening of all of our shows, special merch deals, and more. Right now, you can use the code "THANKS" for 20% off of an annual membership.