Big Box USA: The Environmental Impact of America's Biggest Retail Stores
Feb 27, 2025
auto_awesome
Rachel Gross, an assistant professor at the University of Colorado Denver and co-editor of *Big Box USA*, dives into the environmental impact of major retail giants like Walmart and REI. She discusses how these stores, while often critiqued for their ecological footprints, can also promote sustainable practices like marine conservation. Gross explores the shifting dynamics of outdoor apparel and identity, revealing the complexities of consumer culture. Join her as she unpacks the intricate relationships between retail, culture, and the environment.
The transition from traditional stores to big box retailers has reshaped consumer experiences and shopping habits across America.
Big box stores exert considerable influence on environmental practices, demonstrating their potential as catalysts for positive ecological policies in industries like fishing.
Cultural tensions between authenticity and accessibility persist as outdoor brands resist the association with big box retailers, fearing a dilution of specialized knowledge.
Deep dives
The Shift to Big Box Retail
The evolution of retail in America has seen a notable transition from traditional mom-and-pop stores to the rise of big box retailers. This shift began with the initial structure of department stores and mail-order systems, which laid the groundwork for the large-scale retail formats we see today. Consumers now encounter massive parking lots and expansive store layouts, moving away from pedestrian-friendly shopping centers of the past. This geographical transformation has changed not just shopping habits, but the very experience of consumerism in the U.S.
Environmental Considerations in Big Box Stores
Big box stores like Walmart and Target have significant environmental implications related to their operations and supply chains. They can influence fishing sustainability and wetlands management through policies and practices that impact ecosystems at large. For instance, Walmart’s fishery sustainability efforts illustrate the potential for large retailers to shape the standards for environmental practices in industries such as fishing. This suggests a complex relationship where big box brands can also be catalysts for positive environmental policy.
The Cultural Tension between Outdoor Brands and Big Box Retail
Outdoor brands like REI and Cabela's often express a cultural resistance to being associated with big box stores like Walmart. Despite the potential for expanded market access through such acquisitions, the outdoor community frequently views these retail giants as misrepresenting the authenticity of outdoor experiences. This sentiment reflects long-standing tensions around consumer identity and the fear that mass-market appeal dilutes the specialized knowledge that smaller retailers embody. The friction between authenticity and accessibility continues to shape the discourse around outdoor retail.
The Influence of Fast Fashion on Outdoor Clothing
The rise of fast fashion has blurred the lines between functional outdoor wear and everyday apparel, leading to outdoor clothing becoming part of mainstream fashion. This shift represents a change in consumer perception, where formerly specialized outdoor attire is embraced for casual use without a genuine connection to outdoor activities. The democratization of outdoor gear means that anyone can purchase and wear such clothing, regardless of their expertise or engagement with nature. This transformation raises questions about identity and what it means to truly participate in outdoor culture.
Rethinking Consumer Impact on the Environment
The environmental footprint of big box retailers extends beyond their immediate surroundings, reflecting broader patterns of consumption and waste. The push for low prices drives consumers to accumulate goods that are often disposed of with little thought for their ecological impact. Empty shopping malls serve as reminders of the transient nature of consumer trends, highlighting the wastefulness associated with retail practices. The ongoing conversation about retail's environmental impact prompts consumers to consider their role within this system and fosters a critical understanding of consumer habits.
Our book is: Big Box USA: The Environmental Impact of America’s Biggest Retail Stores (UP of Colorado, 2024)which presents a new look at how the big box retail store has dramatically reshaped the US economy and its ecosystems in the last half century. From the rural South to the frigid North, from inside stores to ecologies far beyond, this book examines the relationships that make up one of the most visible features of late twentieth-century and early twenty-first-century American life. The rise of big box retail since the 1960s has transformed environments on both local and global scales. Almost everyone has explored the aisles of big box stores. The allure of “everyday low prices” and brightly colored products of every kind connect shoppers with a global marketplace. Contributors join a growing conversation between business and environmental history, addressing the ways American retail institutions have affected physical and cultural ecologies around the world. Essays on Walmart, Target, Cabela’s, REI, and Bass Pro Shops assess the “bigness” of these superstores from “smokestacks to coat racks” and contend that their ecological impacts are not limited to the footprints of parking lots and manufacturing but also play a didactic role in educating consumers about their relationships with the environment. A model for historians seeking to bring business and environmental histories together in their analyses of merchant capital’s role in the landscapes of everyday life and how it has remade human relationships with nature, Big Box USA is a must-read for students and scholars of the environment, business, sustainability, retail professionals, and a general audience.
Our guest is: Dr. Rachel Gross, who is assistant professor of history at the University of Colorado Denver, where she teaches US environmental, business, and public history. She works with university and community partners to bring history into the public realm. She is the author of Shopping All the Way to the Woods: How the Outdoor Industry Sold Nature to America, and the co-editor of Big Box USA: The Environmental Impact of America’s Biggest Retail Stores.
Our host is: Dr. Christina Gessler, who is the creator, producer and show host of the Academic Life podcast. She uses her PhD in history to explore what stories we tell, and what happens to those we never tell.
Welcome to Academic Life, the podcast for your academic journey—and beyond! You can support the show by downloading or sharing episodes. Join us again to learn from more experts inside and outside the academy, and around the world. Missed any of the 240+ Academic Life episodes? Find them here. And thank you for listening!
