Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning

Jacob Shell: academia must diversify or die

May 2, 2025
In this conversation, Jacob Shell, a geography professor at Temple University and author, addresses the urgent need for ideological diversity in academia. He argues that the current left-leaning dominance stifles intellectual discourse and suggests hiring more conservative scholars to enhance academic integrity. Shell critiques the politicization of academia and examines how informal screening mechanisms hinder conservative voices. He also discusses the challenges posed by the grant system and the need for a reformed approach to ensure inclusivity and rigorous scholarship.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Ideological Monoculture in Academia

  • US academia is dominated by left-leaning faculty, leading to ideological monoculture and political vulnerability.
  • Conservatives are informally discouraged or excluded, but many agree with the need for ideological diversity.
INSIGHT

2016 Election Changed Academia's Role

  • The 2016 election marked a shift where many academics began leveraging their work to support the Democratic Party.
  • This politicization risks undermining academia's role as an independent knowledge producer.
ADVICE

Cluster Hire Conservatives Strategically

  • Hiring conservative professors requires cluster hires to avoid tokenization and group isolation.
  • Intellectual diversification can be achieved by redirecting hiring to value skills, not just ideology.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app