Laura Meckler, a national education writer for the Washington Post, and Russell Shaw, head of Georgetown Day School and author on phone bans in education, dive into the impact of smartphones on student interactions. They discuss how phone bans are becoming a trend to combat rising anxiety and promote genuine connections in schools. The conversation also highlights the mixed responses to these policies and the delicate balance of managing technology use amidst ongoing mental health concerns.
Removing cell phones in schools aims to combat rising anxiety and social disconnection among students by fostering genuine interactions.
The response to phone bans highlights a divide between perceived benefits of reduced distractions and concerns over safety and technology education.
Deep dives
The Shift in Student Interactions
Over the years, there has been a notable shift in how students engage with one another within school settings. Traditionally, students were more present and engaged with their peers, but now many are more focused on their devices, often even while in groups. This change has led to a decrease in spontaneous social interactions and the collective joy that once characterized high school environments. As one educator pointed out, students now often resort to their phones during awkward moments rather than initiating conversations, which can lead to increased isolation among them.
Impact of Technology on Mental Health
The rising concerns regarding adolescent mental health have prompted schools to consider banning cell phones as a means of fostering better environments for students. Schools are observing a national increase in anxiety, depression, and social disconnection among students, prompting administrators to reassess the role of technology in their lives. Many educators believe that while technology was initially designed to connect individuals, it has inadvertently become a barrier to genuine relationships and emotional well-being. By limiting phone usage, schools hope to encourage real-life interactions that support student mental health and create a grounded sense of community.
Varied Responses to Phone Bans
The response to school cell phone bans has been mixed, with varying opinions among students, parents, and educators. Many teachers and administrators appreciate the decreased distractions and improved social dynamics observed when phones are restricted, leading to students engaging more with each other. However, some students contest that banning phones does not teach responsible usage of technology, while parents express concerns over safety and being able to reach their children during emergencies. Ultimately, while many agree that limiting phone access is a step towards addressing broader mental health challenges, they recognize it is not a complete solution to issues affecting today's youth.
Since the pandemic, schools have been reporting that their students are more anxious and having trouble learning. How much does simply removing cell phones from the classroom address these problems?
Guests:
Laura Meckler, national education writer for the Washington Post
Want more What Next TBD? Subscribe to Slate Plus to access ad-free listening to the whole What Next family and all your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe today on Apple Podcasts by clicking “Try Free” at the top of our show page. Sign up now at slate.com/whatnextplus to get access wherever you listen.