Seabed mining holds promise for extracting critical minerals needed for the energy transition, but balancing economic potential with potential environmental impacts is a key challenge.
Enforcing strong regulations and ensuring compliance in deep-sea mining sites, both within exclusive economic zones and beyond national jurisdiction, remains a significant challenge that requires ongoing attention.
Deep dives
The Potential of Seabed Mining for Critical Minerals
Seabed mining holds promise for extracting critical minerals needed for the energy transition. Nickel, cobalt, copper, and other metals are present in polymetallic nodules found at the ocean floor. The estimated resources are substantial, with some areas containing more nickel than the entire global terrestrial nickel resource. The challenge lies in balancing the economic potential with the potential environmental impacts. The main concern against seabed mining is the lack of understanding of deep-sea ecosystems and the unknown impacts of mining activities. To address this, robust environmental studies and baseline research are crucial. Mitigation strategies, such as large offset areas and engineering solutions to minimize disturbance, are being explored. Permitting and enforcement are key challenges in ensuring that strong regulations are implemented and followed. The industry is expected to progress, with mining activities potentially beginning in exclusive economic zones first. However, investor stewardship and demands for sustainability standards could play a significant role in shaping the industry in the future. Commercial-scale recovery of seabed minerals could potentially occur around 2028, but there are uncertainties regarding specific timelines and locations.
Regulatory Landscape and Enforcement Challenges
The International Seabed Authority (ISA) governs seabed mining activities in international waters. Current regulations cover exploration, and the approval of exploitation regulations is underway. The regulatory framework is designed to balance resource exploitation and environmental protection. The challenge lies in enforcing these regulations, given the isolation and complexity of deep-sea mining sites. Monitoring mechanisms and independent expert bodies are needed to review mining companies' environmental data and ensure compliance. The strength of regulators to halt mining activities if impacts exceed permitted levels is essential. Deep-sea mining in exclusive economic zones may progress more quickly due to stronger regulatory bodies and established processes. However, effective enforcement beyond national jurisdiction remains a significant challenge that requires ongoing attention.
Technologies and Impacts of Seabed Mining
Two main technologies are being explored for seabed mining: dredge-based systems and selective harvesting. Dredge-based systems involve extracting polymetallic nodules and associated sediment from the seabed, with efforts focused on minimizing sediment plumes and offsetting impacted areas. Selective harvesting, an emerging technology, aims to minimize disturbance by using underwater vehicles to pick up nodules individually without coming into contact with the sediment. This method offers potential benefits for preserving ecosystem connectivity and leaving a percentage of nodules behind. However, further research and testing are necessary. The economic feasibility of these technologies is another aspect under consideration. The industry is actively working on developing mitigation strategies and optimizing environmental impacts to meet regulatory requirements and ensure the sustainable extraction of critical minerals.
The Future of Seabed Mining
The future of seabed mining is multifaceted and marked by ongoing debates and uncertainties. There is a likelihood of mining activities beginning in exclusive economic zones, driven by stronger regulatory environments. The International Seabed Authority is expected to approve exploitation regulations, laying the framework for future mining applications. However, permitting, regulation enforcement, and ongoing monitoring pose significant challenges. The industry is striving to meet environmental and sustainability standards, with potential influence from investor demands for stewardship. The first commercial-scale recovery of seabed minerals could occur around 2028, but uncertainties remain regarding specific timelines and locations. Continued research, regulatory advancements, and responsible practices will be essential for balancing mineral resource extraction with the protection of deep-sea ecosystems.
The good news: The Clarion-Clipperton Zone (CCZ) contains more nickel and cobalt than the rest of the world’s land-based reserves combined. It also has significant resources of high-grade lithium, copper and rare earth metals—all of which are critical for the batteries the world needs to meet Paris Agreement targets.
The bad news: The CCZ lies at the bottom of the Pacific Ocean and contains biodiverse ecosystems we know very little about—and that we could profoundly harm if we mine them.
The CCZ lies between Hawaii and Mexico and is about half the size of the continental United States. And it’s just one of many potential deep-sea sources of critical minerals.
So should we mine the deep sea to fight climate change? And if we do, how do we also protect seafloor ecosystems?
In this episode, Shayle talks to Renee Grogan, an expert in deep-sea mining. She is a co-founder and board director at Impossible Metals.
Together they cover topics like:
The different types of seafloor resources, including polymetallic nodules, cobalt ferro-manganese crusts, and massive sulfides
Better understanding seafloor ecosystems and incorporating science into mining practices and regulations, including selective harvesting, protected areas, and offsets
The challenges of enforcing regulations three to five kilometers below the surface
Ongoing negotiations at the International Seabed Authority, which was planning to finalize regulations for deep-sea mining last week, but announced that it needed more time.
Recommended Resources:
NYT: Pacific Seabed Mining Delayed as International Agency Finalizes Rules
Forbes: Deep Sea Mining: The Biggest Climate Issue You’ve Never Heard Of
Catalyst is supported by Antenna Group. For 25 years, Antenna has partnered with leading clean-economy innovators to build their brands and accelerate business growth. If you're a startup, investor, enterprise, or innovation ecosystem that's creating positive change, Antenna is ready to power your impact. Visit antennagroup.com to learn more.
Catalyst is supported by RE+. RE+ is more than just the largest clean energy event, it’s a catalyst for industry innovation designed to supercharge business growth in the clean energy economy. Learn more: re-plus.com.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode