A dive into the shifting role of real estate agents reveals the pressures of a declining housing market. Traditional brokerages face challenges from low-cost, cloud-based competitors that attract agents with better commission structures. The discussion highlights the evolving regulatory landscape and its long-term implications. Financial strategies and the impact of agent attrition create further complexities. The transformation of the brokerage model sets the stage for new opportunities in an industry grappling with change.
The residential real estate market is currently challenged by a significant decrease in agent productivity, leading to heightened competition among agents for a limited number of existing home sales.
Cloud-based real estate brokerages are transforming the industry by offering agents higher commission retention rates and opportunities for residual income, attracting talent away from traditional firms.
Deep dives
Challenges Facing Real Estate Agents
The real estate market is experiencing significant challenges, particularly for real estate agents, as existing home sales remain at multi-decade lows. Agents affiliated with Anywhere Real Estate are reportedly conducting an average of only five transactions per year, translating to less than one deal every two months. This figure has decreased by roughly one-third over the past five years, highlighting the competitive nature of the market, with 1.5 million licensed agents vying for only 4 million existing home sales. These conditions are expected to lead many agents to leave the industry, exacerbating the strain on traditional brokerages that depend on agent productivity for revenue.
Emergence of Cloud-Based Brokerages
Cloud-based real estate brokerages are presenting new opportunities for agents by allowing them to retain a larger portion of their commissions compared to traditional firms. While traditional brokerages typically allow agents to keep around 80% of their commissions, these newer platforms enable agents to retain up to 90%. Additionally, agents who recruit others to join these cloud-based brokerages can earn residual income from their recruits' transactions, creating a sustainable revenue stream. As a result, this model is attracting agents away from traditional firms, indicating a shift in the competitive landscape.
Impact of Industry Changes on Traditional Brokerages
Traditional brokerages are facing an uphill battle as they contend with declining agent numbers and increasing competition from cloud-based competitors. Although it is commonly believed that brokerages like Anywhere and Remax will rebound when the housing market improves, the loss of agents is diminishing their ability to capitalize on a recovery. Without sufficient agents to market and close deals, these brokerages risk falling into a negative cycle of reduced visibility and financial performance. Furthermore, the recent NAR settlement and potential restructuring of commission models pose additional uncertainties that could further impact the traditional real estate brokerage model.
In this episode of the Know More. Risk Better. podcast, Winnie Cisar, Global Head of Strategy at CreditSights, and Senior Special Situations Analyst, Peter Sakon, dive into the evolving residential real estate brokerage industry. They discuss the challenges faced by real estate agents, traditional brokerages like Anywhere Real Estate’s (HOUS) Century 21 and RE/MAX (RMAX), the rise of low-cost cloud-based competitors, and new regulations from the National Association of Realtors. The conversation also touches on the financial pressures on these companies and potential long-term risks.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode