The Daily The Supreme Court Considers the Future of Roe
Dec 2, 2021
Adam Liptak, a Supreme Court reporter for The New York Times, dives into the pivotal case challenging Roe v. Wade. He discusses the conservative majority's influence on abortion laws and the ramifications of a Mississippi law that limits abortions after 15 weeks. Liptak uncovers key arguments from both sides and explores the philosophical debates surrounding women's rights versus state control. The conversation also highlights Chief Justice Roberts' attempts to reach a compromise in this divisive legal battle, underscoring the potential risks to reproductive freedoms.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Dobbs v. Jackson Challenges Roe
- The case Dobbs v. Jackson challenges Roe v. Wade, aiming to allow states to ban abortions.
- It concerns a Mississippi law banning abortions after 15 weeks, contradicting Roe's viability standard.
Viability as the Core of Roe
- The core of Roe v. Wade is the viability standard, preventing abortion bans before fetal survival outside the womb.
- Mississippi's 15-week ban directly contradicts this, requiring Roe's weakening for the law to stand.
Liberal Justices Defend Roe
- Liberal justices defend Roe, emphasizing its long-standing nature and the potential damage to the court's image if overturned.
- They believe overturning Roe based on personnel changes would make the court appear political.