Fabienne Peter, a Professor of Philosophy, dives into John Rawls' transformative theory of justice, while Martin O’Neill sheds light on Rawls' background and philosophical influences. Jonathan Wolff evaluates Rawls' radical ideas on economic inequality and the 'justice as fairness' framework. The conversation also tackles the feasibility of Rawls' property-owning democracy and critiques associated with racial justice. They discuss how Rawlsian principles can guide public policy and the ongoing relevance of his insights in today’s democratic societies.
Rawls' theory of justice advocated for inequalities in society to benefit the worst off, not the richest.
Reflective equilibrium and the role of democracy were key aspects of Rawls' theory of justice.
Rawls' ideas extended beyond political philosophy, influencing moral philosophy and the work of his students.
Deep dives
A Theory of Justice and its Influence on Political Philosophy
John Rawls' book, A Theory of Justice, is considered one of the most influential works in 20th century political philosophy. Rawls drew on his own experiences in World War II and aimed to create a just society based on personal liberty and fair equality of opportunity. His radical idea was that any inequalities in society should benefit the worst off, rather than the richest. Rawls' background, including his time in the army and loss of faith in divine providence, shaped his philosophy. The political and social backdrop in the US, including the New Deal, Vietnam War, and civil rights movement, influenced Rawls' ideas. He explored utilitarianism and its shortcomings, introducing the concept of intuitionism as an alternative. Rawls also emphasized the importance of the original position, a thought experiment where people make decisions about a just society from behind a veil of ignorance. His theory of justice is based on two main principles: equal liberties for all and fair equality of opportunity. Additionally, Rawls proposed the difference principle, which states that a just society should benefit the worst off. Despite criticisms and varying interpretations, A Theory of Justice continues to be widely studied and considered in academic and policy discussions.
Reflective Equilibrium and the Role of Democracy
Rawls introduced the concept of reflective equilibrium as a method of justification for moral claims. Reflective equilibrium involves achieving coherence between moral ideas at different levels of generality, ranging from particular judgments to more general principles. Rawls believed that moral justification should not be solely based on truth or evidence, but on achieving agreement among individuals who are seen as equals. This idea is linked to the social contract tradition and emphasizes the significance of fair procedures. Rawls also highlighted the importance of a full reflective equilibrium, which involves achieving agreement among a group of individuals. Additionally, Rawls emphasized the value of democracy in his theory. He believed that a just society is one where everyone is considered equal, and democracy provides a platform for individuals to participate in shaping and evolving the principles and institutions of society. While Rawls' theory has faced criticisms, such as its compatibility with historical injustices or its potential conflict with democratic decision-making, his emphasis on reflective equilibrium and the role of democracy remains influential.
Rawls' Critique of Capitalism and Legacy on Public Policy
Rawls' work reflects a critique of capitalist societies and the pursuit of justice within them. While Rawls acknowledged the benefits of certain redistributive welfare states, he argued that they fell short of achieving a just society. He proposed the idea of a property-owning democracy, advocating for a broad distribution of wealth and capital, or a liberal socialist regime that combined individual liberties with public and collective ownership. Rawls' influence extends beyond academia, as his ideas have shaped public policy discussions. Many policymakers, both on the left and the right, prioritize addressing the needs of the least advantaged in society, aligning with Rawls' emphasis on improving the position of the worst off. Despite the challenges and ongoing debates surrounding Rawls' theories, his profound impact on political philosophy and public policy is evident.
Rawls' Contribution to Moral Philosophy and the Legacy of his Students
Rawls' contribution to moral philosophy extends beyond political philosophy. He developed the idea of reflective equilibrium as a method for assessing moral claims, aiming for coherence across moral judgments at different levels of generality. Rawls' influence can also be seen in the work of his students, who expanded on his Kantian ideas. Many of his students, both male and female, became influential philosophers in their own right and contributed to moral philosophy. Elizabeth Anderson, Michelle Moody Adams, Christine Korsgaard, and Barbara Herman are among those who further developed and advanced Rawlsian ideas. Rawls' impact on moral philosophy continues to invigorate debates on Kantian ethics and moral theories. While Rawls faced criticisms and ongoing discussions surrounding his theories, his ideas and the work of his students have left a lasting legacy in the field of moral philosophy.
The Role of Democracy and Rawls' Disappointment in Society
Rawls viewed democracy as a central aspect of his theory, emphasizing the importance of democracy for the realization of justice. Democracy is seen as a vehicle for achieving fairness, equality, and reciprocal treatment among free and equal citizens. Rawls' concept of justice as fairness relies on a commitment to democracy and the idea of equal participation in the development of society. However, recent disillusionment with democracy raises questions about its compatibility with Rawls' vision. Rolzian disappointment in society stemmed from the observed departure from equality and justice. The growing wealth disparities and inequalities in society have prompted criticism of democratic institutions. Despite the challenges to democracy and ongoing debates, Rawls saw the significance of democracy in achieving a just society and ensuring fair and reciprocal treatment among individuals.
Melvyn Bragg and guests discuss A Theory of Justice by John Rawls (1921 - 2002) which has been called the most influential book in twentieth century political philosophy. It was first published in 1971. Rawls (pictured above) drew on his own experience in WW2 and saw the chance in its aftermath to build a new society, one founded on personal liberty and fair equality of opportunity. While in that just society there could be inequalities, Rawls’ radical idea was that those inequalities must be to the greatest advantage not to the richest but to the worst off.
With
Fabienne Peter
Professor of Philosophy at the University of Warwick
Martin O’Neill
Professor of Political Philosophy at the University of York
And
Jonathan Wolff
The Alfred Landecker Professor of Values and Public Policy at the Blavatnik School of Government, University of Oxford and Fellow of Wolfson College
Producer: Simon Tillotson
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
