Michele Gelfand, a cultural psychologist and author of "Rule Makers, Rule Breakers," joins to discuss her groundbreaking theory on cultural tightness and looseness. She breaks down how societies can be classified along this spectrum and the implications for behavior and rule enforcement. Gelfand sheds light on why some cultures prioritize order, especially in times of chaos, and examines how various factors influence these cultural dynamics. The conversation also touches on the recent verdict in the controversial Daniel Penny trial, unpacking the polarized narratives surrounding it.
Michele Gelfand introduces the concept of 'tight' and 'loose' cultures, emphasizing how historical threats shape societal adherence to rules.
The controversial Daniel Penny trial highlights polarized reactions across political lines, revealing complexities in public sentiment regarding race and justice.
Deep dives
Us Days Promotions by U.S. Cellular
U.S. Cellular is offering exclusive promotions during Us Days, which includes significant discounts for customers. The current deals feature up to $1,200 off any phone and $400 off any tablet, capturing attention as exciting offers just in time for the holiday season. Family members are thrilled about the new devices that the promotions enable, underlining the value of these discounts in improving connectivity and entertainment. The emphasis on appreciation for customers showcases U.S. Cellular's commitment to rewarding loyalty.
Interview with Professor Michelle Gelfand
Professor Michelle Gelfand introduces the concept of categorizing cultures on a spectrum of 'tight' and 'loose' rather than traditional cultural metrics like openness to immigration or trade policies. Tight cultures exhibit strong adherence to social rules, while loose cultures allow for more flexibility and variation in behavior. Gelfand provides examples, contrasting the orderly behavior in countries like Germany and Singapore with the more relaxed norms found in places like New Zealand and Brazil. The discussion highlights how the need for rules often correlates with societal threats, suggesting that historical challenges shape cultural responses.
Analysis of the Daniel Penny Trial
The podcast delves into the controversial trial of Daniel Penny, who was acquitted after choking Jordan Neely, a man he claimed was threatening subway passengers. The ruling elicited strong emotional responses from various political and social groups, with viewpoints significantly divided along ideological lines. The speaker critiques the media coverage and the framing of the events, noting how narratives surrounding the case differ based on political affiliations and personal beliefs. Observations about the lack of widespread protests following the trial verdict highlight the complexity of public sentiment regarding issues of race and justice.
Cultural Differences in Response to Norm Violation
The conversation includes insights into how different social classes react to rule violations, particularly focusing on children from various socioeconomic backgrounds. Studies show that working-class children display a stronger preference for adherence to rules, feeling more discomfort when norms are violated, whereas middle-class children might find such violations amusing. This discrepancy illustrates the cultural and educational impacts that wealth and upbringing have on behavior and the perceived importance of rules. The discussion reinforces the idea that understanding these different mindsets can aid in addressing the challenges that arise in culturally diverse environments.
Each weekend on Best Of The Gist, we revisit an archival segment from the past and pair it with a replay of something from the past week. This weekend, we revisit Mike’s 2018 interview with cultural psychologist Michele Gelfand, who challenges us to think of societies not along the traditional “liberal to conservative” spectrum but instead as ranging from “tight to loose.” It’s a theory she explores in her book Rule Makers, Rule Breakers: How Tight and Loose Cultures Wire Our World. From the past week, we replay Mike’s Tuesday Spiel about the acquittal of Daniel Penny.
SUBSCRIBE
We offer premium subscriptions, including an AD-FREE version of the show and options for bonus content.
The Gist is produced by Joel Patterson and Corey Wara