715: How to Stand Up for Yourself, with Sunita Sah
Jan 13, 2025
auto_awesome
Sunita Sah, an award-winning professor at Cornell and author of *Defy: The Power of No in a World That Demands Yes*, shares her insights on defiance and compliance. She discusses how defiance is a nuanced process rather than a snap judgement. Sunita explains the five stages of defiance and highlights the concept of ‘insinuation anxiety,’ which leads people to prioritize social harmony over personal values. Through personal anecdotes, she emphasizes the importance of standing firm in healthcare choices and asserts that true defiance aligns with one’s core values.
Defiance involves a deliberate process that allows individuals to align their actions with their values when faced with pressure.
Understanding the stages of defiance and self-reflection through the defiance compass can empower individuals to assertively navigate challenging situations.
Deep dives
Understanding Defiance and Compliance
Defiance is often perceived as a spontaneous act but is more accurately a nuanced response to specific pressures. Compliance, while sometimes essential, can lead to detrimental outcomes when it contradicts personal values or common sense. The podcast emphasizes that successfully standing up for oneself requires understanding when to say no, rather than simply going along with expectations. An example highlighted involves a medical professional’s experience in the emergency room, illustrating the tension between compliance and critical self-advocacy.
The Concept of Insinuation Anxiety
Insinuation anxiety refers to the discomfort felt when deciding not to comply with someone else's request, stemming from fear of appearing untrustworthy or harmful. This emotional state can pressure individuals to acquiesce, even when they know the advice or demand is not in their best interest. The discussion surrounding this term sheds light on the psychological barriers that prevent us from asserting our preferences or values in interpersonal interactions. By recognizing the influence of this anxiety, individuals can better navigate decisions without compromising their integrity.
Defiance as a Skill to be Developed
Defiance can be cultivated as a skill rather than being relegated to those with inherently strong personalities. The concept is illustrated through historical figures like Rosa Parks, whose resistance was rooted in a lifetime of preparation and prior experiences that shaped her defiant moment. It is noted that the act of defiance involves a process, where individuals can develop their ability to stand up against pressures that conflict with their values. Understanding the stages of defiance can empower individuals to recognize tensions and articulate their discomfort effectively.
The Defiance Compass and Its Application
The defiance compass serves as a practical tool for individuals to assess their values and the appropriateness of defiance in various situations. It prompts self-reflection through three critical questions: Who am I? What type of situation is this? and What would a person like me do? By explicitly answering these questions, individuals can bridge the gap between their values and actions, enhancing their ability to act in alignment with their true selves. Through personal stories, the podcast illustrates how employing the defiance compass can lead to positive outcomes, both personally and in broader contexts.
Sunita Sah is an award-winning professor at Cornell University and an expert in organizational psychology, leading groundbreaking research on influence, authority, compliance, and defiance. A trained physician, her research and analyses have been widely published in leading academic journals and media entities including The New York Times, Los Angeles Times, Harvard Business Review, and Scientific American. She is the author of Defy: The Power of No in a World That Demands Yes*.
We often think of defiance as a snap judgement. Yet, it’s so much more nuanced and purposeful than it often appears. In this conversation, Sunita and I explore the common patterns of defiance and how we can all do a better job of standing up for ourselves.
Key Points
We follow bad advice – even when we know it is obviously bad – to avoid appearing unhelpful.
Defiance means acting in accordance with your true values when there is pressure to do otherwise.
True defiance is not a snap judgement; it’s a process.
Acts of defiance are preceded by many moments of conscious compliance, when defiance is deferred.
Five stages of defiance often emerge: (1) Tension, (2) Acknowledgement (to ourselves), (3) Escalation (vocalize to others), (4) Threat of non-compliance, and (5) Act of defiance.
Vocalizing our concern to someone else is a key pivot point on the journey to ultimately saying no.
Respond explicitly to these questions: (1) Who am I? (2) What type of situation is this? and (3) What does a person like me do in a situation such as this?