Melanie Rieback, a cybersecurity entrepreneur and founder of Nonprofit Ventures, discusses her journey into post-growth entrepreneurship—eschewing the traditional Silicon Valley model for sustainable practices. She critiques the conventional capitalist framework and emphasizes the importance of ethical governance models like steward ownership. Rieback highlights the concept of non-extractive business practices, addressing fair compensation challenges while advocating for systemic change. Engaging personal experiences are also underscored as vital for shaping this innovative landscape.
Post-growth entrepreneurship prioritizes social impact over profit maximization by rejecting the typical Silicon Valley model of rapid growth and exit strategies.
Innovative governance mechanisms, such as asset locks, are essential for ensuring that businesses remain accountable to their ethical commitments and social purposes.
A cultural shift toward cooperation and shared values is necessary for promoting non-extractive business practices and challenging the prevailing status quo.
Deep dives
The Concept of Post-Growth Entrepreneurship
Post-growth entrepreneurship refers to businesses structured to avoid financial extraction and to operate with a focus on social impact over profit maximization. This model seeks to redefine the traditional notion of entrepreneurship, particularly by going beyond the standard Silicon Valley approach, which often prioritizes rapid growth and exit strategies. By adopting governance structures that limit profit motives, companies can align their operations more closely with ethical practices and long-term sustainability. The discussion includes the principles that underpin post-growth models, emphasizing that impact should be the sole motivation for a business's existence.
Challenges with Existing Business Models
The current business landscape, especially in Silicon Valley, often perpetuates income inequality and fosters extractive financial practices. Many startup incubators, while presenting themselves as supportive of entrepreneurs, are actually incentivized to push for excessive growth and quick exits, effectively sidelining more sustainable business practices. Melanie Ryback highlights that traditional venture capital compensation structures, where fund managers benefit from rapid growth, create misaligned incentives that contribute to a cycle of failure among many startups. The dominating narrative of growth-driven entrepreneurship often leads to a misalignment of values between what companies claim to represent and their actual operational objectives.
Leveraging Corporate Governance for Change
Corporate governance serves as a critical leverage point for systemic change within the realm of business, particularly through the lens of financial non-extractiveness. By employing governance mechanisms such as golden shares—shares that confer voting but not profit rights—companies can guard against mission drift and preserve their ethical commitments. The podcast discusses the need for innovative governance that holds companies accountable to their stated social purposes, drawing parallels with historical examples like OpenAI, where inadequate governance structures allowed for mission divergence. Suggested reforms revolve around institutional changes that can redefine fiduciary responsibilities to include social and environmental considerations.
Bootstrapping, Flat Growth, and Non-Extraction Principles
Post-growth entrepreneurship encourages bootstrapping, where businesses develop without relying on external investments, allowing for greater financial independence and lower dependency on extractive capitalist practices. This approach advocates for flat growth—aligning revenue with operational costs to promote stability over hypergrowth—which leads to sustainable business development. By focusing on intrinsic value creation and strong relationships with customers, these principles enable companies to thrive in a more meaningful way, compared to traditional growth models that lead to over-leverage and financial instability. This method not only fosters resilience in business operations but also empowers entrepreneurs to innovate within the constraints of their means rather than through excessive capital influx.
Cultural Shifts within Entrepreneurship
The cultural aspect of business practices plays a vital role in successfully implementing post-growth entrepreneurship. Melanie Ryback emphasizes the need for a cultural shift that transcends typical political divides, encouraging collaboration across diverse ideologies to foster shared values like financial non-extraction. Drawing parallels between historical religious teachings and modern economic practices reveals potential alliances that can strengthen the movement toward ethical business practices. Ultimately, cultivating a culture of cooperation and understanding within the entrepreneurial space is essential for challenging the status quo and enabling broader systemic change.
Melanie Rieback is a cybersecurity entrepreneur and the founder of Nonprofit Ventures, an organization dedicated to supporting post growth entrepreneurs. She runs an incubator to support post growth entrepreneurs and teaches a course at the University of Amsterdam on post growth entrepreneurship. Her lectures are available on YouTube, linked below.
This episode builds on a long series of conversations on this podcast exploring economic reform: stakeholder capitalism, steward ownership, co-ops, post-growth economics, to name a few. While it's called pot growth entrepreneurship, really this conversation is about non-extractive entrepreneurship. PGE rejects the typical silicon valley model of capital, scale, exit, in favor of bootstrapping, flat growth, and non-extraction.
In this conversation Jenny and Melanie discuss:
Melanie's path from cybersecurity entrepreneur to post growth entrepreneurship
Why not all forms of steward ownership ensure profit serves purpose
Why Melanie believes business is one of the most effective forms of activism
Defining post growth entrepreneurship (PGE)
Why PGE is a leverage point for systemic change
Issues with the Silicon Valley model of capital, scale, exit
Issues with status quo social enterprise and impact investing
Principles of PGE: bootstrapping, flat growth, non-extraction
Asset locks and stable steward ownership implementation
Policy initiatives in Europe to create a steward owned business entity
How to think about fair compensation when implementing PGE
Melanie's post growth entrepreneurship course at the University of Amsterdam; 8 YouTube lectures
To stay connected to all things Denizen, you can sign up for our newsletter at www.becomingdenizen.com. There we share our latest content alongside community events, educational opportunities, and announcements from our many partner organizations.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode