Lesley Stockton, a Wirecutter staff writer with a rich background in professional kitchens, dives into the buttery world of cooking and baking. She shares insights on selecting the best butters for various culinary uses and reveals fascinating differences between grass-fed and grain-fed varieties. The conversation includes a fun taste test of 17 different butters, emphasizing how quality impacts flavor and texture, especially in beloved desserts like pie. Lesley also provides holiday baking tips and explores the rise of vegan butter alternatives.
The podcast highlights the contrasting perspectives on butter, emphasizing its essential role in cooking despite dietary restrictions faced by some individuals.
A detailed taste test reveals that the quality of butter, particularly from grass-fed cows, significantly impacts flavor and texture in culinary applications.
Deep dives
The Butter Debate
The podcast delves into the contrasting views on butter held by two hosts, Christine and Kyra. While Christine passionately advocates for butter as a culinary staple, Kyra reveals her dietary restrictions that prevent her from consuming it. This divergence leads to a light-hearted exploration of the significance of butter in various dishes and its role in traditional cooking. The discussion sets the stage for a detailed taste test and review of different butter varieties from the team.
Understanding Butter Quality
The episode emphasizes the importance of butter quality, highlighting how the diet of cows affects the flavor and texture of the final product. Butter produced from grass-fed cows has a richer flavor profile due to the presence of beta-carotene, which gives it a vibrant yellow color. In contrast, butter from grain-fed cows often lacks flavor and can be crumbly in texture. This foundation sets the podcast on a path to sorting through the best butter choices for various culinary uses.
European vs. Domestic Butter
A substantial discussion revolves around the differences between European and American butter, with the former often being favored for its superior quality. European butters, like Kerrygold and Isigni Saint-Mer, are typically grass-fed and sometimes cultured, resulting in a more complex flavor profile. The fermentation process in cultured butters adds a unique tang that enhances their culinary appeal. In comparison, American butters may fall short in both flavor depth and texture, which has implications for baking and cooking.
Taste Testing Insights
The hosts recount their rigorous butter taste test, evaluating 17 types through various methods, including spreading on bread and mixing with pasta. They observed distinct differences in mouthfeel and flavor at different temperatures, which influenced their preferences. While certain butters excelled with a smooth and rich taste, others were critiqued for a lackluster mouthfeel. The episode concludes with a clear endorsement of specific brands that stood out as superior options for baking and spreading.