

#210 Read Church History, Cease To Be Protestant - Joe Heschmeyer
21 snips Sep 25, 2025
Joe Heschmeyer delves into two intriguing conversions from Protestantism to more ancient forms of Christianity. He shares Ben's transformation from anti-Catholic views to Eastern Orthodoxy, and Matthew's shift from Baptist beliefs to Anglicanism, highlighting how these journeys challenge Protestant claims to historical continuity. The discussion touches on the implications of baptism, relevance of church councils, and the limitations of Sola Scriptura. Joe advocates for reconnecting with historic Christianity and urges Catholics to cultivate understanding and respect for these transitions.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
YouTuber's Private Journey Becomes Public
- Cleave to Antiquity (Ben) publicly moved from making anti‑Catholic/Orthodox content to announcing his conversion to Eastern Orthodoxy.
- Joe interprets Ben's earlier hostility as part of his private grappling with objections rather than final rejection.
Prominent Reformer Becomes Anglican
- Matthew Barrett, a Baptist and author defending Protestant continuity, announced he's becoming Anglican.
- Joe notes Barrett's move places him in a tradition that rejects Sola Scriptura and emphasizes creeds, councils, and bishops.
Historic Credibility Project Fails
- Both Ben and Barrett aimed to show Protestantism's historical credibility but ultimately found that project untenable.
- Joe suggests sincere engagement with antiquity often leads away from modern Protestant forms.