Should I have a kid? The mother of all decisions with Gina Rushton and Penny Greenhalgh
Feb 17, 2025
auto_awesome
Gina Rushton, a journalist and author who tackles the monumental choice of having children, joins Penny Greenhalgh, a comedian, exploring the emotional turmoil surrounding motherhood decisions. They dive into societal pressures and personal dilemmas faced by women in their late 30s, discussing the stigma of choosing childlessness. The conversation touches on fertility anxieties, the impact of 'heteropessimism' on women's relationships, and the idea of parallel lives. Their candid reflections offer a thoughtful look at the complexities of this life-altering choice.
The decision to have children is deeply influenced by personal experiences, societal pressures, and the ticking biological clock women navigate in their 30s.
Redefining motherhood beyond traditional norms allows for community-centered caregiving, acknowledging love and support can flourish in diverse forms outside biological relationships.
Deep dives
Navigating the Decision of Motherhood
The decision to become a mother often brings conflicting feelings and societal pressures. Women in their 30s, like Gina and Penny, face the challenge of weighing their desires for motherhood against biological constraints, with fertility fears looming over their choices. Gina's personal experience, which involved a serious health scare affecting her fertility, forced her to confront her long-held belief that she did not want children, leading her to begin exploring the real possibility of motherhood. Penny, on the other hand, found herself considering motherhood only as she approached the end of her 30s, realizing that the societal timelines of relationships and parenthood were not aligning with her personal journey.
Generational Impacts on Parenting Choices
The conversation highlights how generational and familial backgrounds heavily influence decisions about parenthood. Both Gina and Penny reflect on their family dynamics—Gina's dysfunctional family background and Penny’s realizations about her role in relationship dynamics—which shape their perspectives on having children. Many women they spoke with expressed fears about repeating generational patterns or about not knowing how to be good parents due to their own upbringing. This introspection often leads to a heavy burden of societal expectations and personal insecurities regarding parenting qualifications.
Redefining Motherhood Beyond Biological Ties
The discussion brings to light the concept that motherhood can take various forms and does not have to adhere to traditional definitions. Penny envisions a community-centered approach to motherhood, where she can provide care and support to friends' children without necessarily having her own. Both women discuss how society tends to devalue non-maternal forms of love and care, suggesting a need to redefine motherhood in more expansive terms. By recognizing that love and caregiving can manifest outside of biological connections, they express a profound understanding of motherhood that aligns with their life choices and values.
Babies. Some women know they want them, others know they absolutely don't, and then there are the women who find themselves trying to make the call one way or another before biology beats them to it.
But how do you weigh up something so monumental? And can you ever be sure that you've made the "right" decision when it comes to starting a family?
Yumi Stynes sits down with journalist and writer, Gina Rushton and comedian, Penny Greenhalgh to discuss this mother of all decisions.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode